Illegal Position Contest!

Sort:
Avatar of EvinSung
Avatar of jhonvincent11

this is truly illegal

Avatar of Arisktotle
EvinSung wrote:
 

#7766 is clearly illegal. But also simpler than its predecessors!

Avatar of n9531l1
Arisktotle wrote:
EvinSung wrote:
 

#7766 is clearly illegal. But also simpler than its predecessors!

Here's what I'm guessing is the easy illegality explanation Arisktotle has in mind.

White's first retraction to uncheck the black king had to be -Bc7xb8. It had to be an uncapture, or else there had to be a black unit at c8 to block queen checks, to give Black a previous move. The capture on b8 or c8, added to the 14 captures by the white pawns, means White needs 15 captures, but Black is only missing 14 units.

Avatar of Arisktotle
EvinSung wrote in #7769:
 

Is legal!

Avatar of n9531l1
EvinSung wrote:
#7769

Seems legal to me.

Avatar of Arisktotle
EvinSung wrote in #7771:

Legal.

Avatar of Leither123

gxf5 b7#

Avatar of EvinSung
Avatar of n9531l1

This is so people can see what #7771 looked like before EvinSung deleted it.

Avatar of EvinSung
Avatar of Leither123
EvinSung wrote:
#7775

The g6 pawn must have originally started on the g-file. Rg7 needs to be set up before the bishops, but both bishops have to be set up before g7-g6 is played, so either Rg7 is impossible or one of the bishops cannot be set up.

Avatar of n9531l1
Avatar of Arisktotle
Leither123 wrote:
EvinSung wrote in #7775:#7775

The g6 pawn must have originally started on the g-file. Rg7 needs to be set up before the bishops, but both bishops have to be set up before g7-g6 is played, so either Rg7 is impossible or one of the bishops cannot be set up.

This is an example of an illegal island. No matter what else is on the board and where, the structure in the upper right is illegal all by itself. I created several retro-problems with such islands. It's very frustrating to unwind a messy diagram and then discover there was an illegal island on the board all the time which you will never ever release. Watch out for those before you waste your time on constructing a proof game!

Avatar of Beanieboos124
Avatar of n9531l1
Avatar of Leither123

Nobody seemed interested in my easy position last time, so here is a slightly harder one.

Avatar of MARattigan

Black has no possible last move.

Edit: Or last but one move if it's Black to play (FEN shoes White, but that can be ignored).

Avatar of EndgameEnthusiast2357
Avatar of EndgameEnthusiast2357

It's illegal because of the pawns, not the kings position.