Illegal Position Contest!

Sort:
Avatar of EvinSung

40

Avatar of n9531l1
Lucas1009991 wrote:

Okay, but why so many positions on this post look legal and normal but they are illegal?

Because that's the kind of position most readers of this thread are hoping to see. Otherwise, there's very little challenge in explaining what makes the position illegal.

Can you explain why my position at #7899 is illegal, if it is?

Avatar of spacecatchess2007
Avatar of Leither123
Avatar of MARattigan

Do you need any more than this?

 
Avatar of Leither123

Accidentally swapped the position of the bishops

Avatar of MARattigan

This enough then?

 
Avatar of Leither123

I don't know how I forgot that black's bishop starts on that square

Avatar of Leither123

I need to stop making last second modifications that I don't check over. The original concept was supposed to have the white bishop in the corner, but I thought it didn't look good enough and shifted the bishops to the center.

This has already happened with at least 3 other positions that I posted.

Avatar of Arisktotle

The last one is still legal!

Avatar of MARattigan
Arisktotle wrote:

The last one is still legal!

How? (Or were you talking about the last last one?)

Avatar of n9531l1
Arisktotle wrote:

The last one is still legal!

It (#7923) certainly is. But I think Leither will find another modification to make it illegal.

Avatar of Arisktotle
MARattigan wrote:
Arisktotle wrote:

The last one is still legal!

How? (Or were you talking about the last last one?)

Yes.

Avatar of MARattigan

Yes, of course!

Avatar of Arisktotle

There is no indication that Leither believed(s) that #7923 was legal.

Avatar of MARattigan

@Arisktotle

I was havering, but you were probably talking about the current last one rather than the last last one, which generally, but rather confusingly in that sort of instance, refers to the one before.

(Who the $%&£ invented English?)

To clarify #7929 was me acknowledging dimness after #7927, but you popped in between.

Avatar of GMKaranveer7
n9531l1 wrote:
GMKaranveer7 wrote:
Chessman265 wrote:

This is a common trick puzzle, because it appears in a semi-famous book, but is it possible for this position to be reached with white to move?

sorry for replying like 7 years late but 1. Nf3 2. e6 3. Ng1 4. e5: white's turn

Why would you even want to repeat an answer that has been posted by others at least a dozen times?

idk

Avatar of n9531l1
Arisktotle wrote:

There is no indication that Leither believed(s) that #7923 was legal.

I think Leither believes you. But just in case...

Avatar of EvinSung
Avatar of Leither123

I might not check over my positions sometimes, but I can still make something that is illegal: