cxd5 instead of c5 wins!

Sort:
RMission

Hi. Need a bit help with explanation on this position. I often end up with similar positions while playing as White where I play simply c5 and my idea remains to restrict the activity of Black's dark square bishop, keeping eye on the center and with some follow up moves like Nd2 and b4 my queenside looks good to me. But engine analysis recognizes this as mistake of not taking proper advantage of Black's weakness. I want to understand what was Black's weakness as Black just played Ne4 and how cxd5 is beneficial for me in long or short run for the rest of the game.  

Any suggestion on which positions to study for clearing similar concepts and how to take good use of these small advantages will be very helpful and appreciated.

blueemu

I wouldn't say that the move 7. cxd5 wins. It gives White the advantage, certainly, because the natural reply 7. ... cxd5 can be met by 8. Bxb8 threatening to win White's Queen with 9. Bb5+. So Black would have to recapture on b8 with his Queen and lose the possibility of castling.

In the generalized position with White Pawns on c4 and d4 facing Black Pawns on d5 and c6, the move c5 (by White) is typically a mistake because it releases the tension in the center and allows Black to play for the strong break e7-e5. 

Henson_Chess

Not a fan of c5, especially if black hasn't committed to a6 yet. It commits to early and telegraphs your intentions to your opponent and releases the tension too early. A future well timed b6 from your opponent could prove to be detrimental to you.  

Blueemu made some great points about tactically winning the queen with Bxb8 and Bb5+. 

PerpetuallyPinned
rahulmukherjee01 wrote:

Hi. Need a bit help with explanation on this position.

Others have addressed this position already. 

I often end up with similar positions while playing as White where I play simply c5 and my idea remains to restrict the activity of Black's dark square bishop,

You could wait for this. Since e6 hasn't been played, Black is doing that for you as it is.

keeping eye on the center

Is c5 "keeping an eye on the center", or is it more like closing the center? Isn't c4 more like keeping an eye on the center with the flexibility to play cxd5 or c5?

and with some follow up moves like Nd2 and b4 my queenside looks good to me.

Is this why you played 5.a3? Were you also looking to limit Black's DSB with a3?

But engine analysis recognizes this as mistake of not taking proper advantage of Black's weakness.

What moves does the engine prefer instead? What moves does the engine suggest after the mistake?

I want to understand what was Black's weakness as Black just played Ne4 and how cxd5 is beneficial for me in long or short run for the rest of the game.

What do you think to be Black's weakness after Ne4? How is Ne4 a mistake? What should Black be doing instead? How can you capitalize on Black's lack in development/loss of time?

Any suggestion on which positions to study for clearing similar concepts and how to take good use of these small advantages will be very helpful and appreciated.

I'd suggest looking at games (older and newer) with similar positions by very strong players. Use a database, even the free ones can be of value. Eric Prie may have some games with similar positions where a3 was played even earlier, but the positions after White's 5th move may be useful.

 

Dsmith42

Actually, looking at this, I'd probably play 7. Bxb8 expecting ..Rxb8 (..Qxb8 8. cxd5 cxd5 9. Bb5+ and black's king is stuck in an exposed central position) 8. cxd5 Qxd5 (..cxd5?? 9. Bb5+ wins the queen) 9. Nc3 forcing a tempo-gaining exchange of knights with a central majority.

The computer is probably seeing 7. cxd5 cxd5 8. Bxb8 Qxb8 (..Rxb8?? Bb5+ as above) 9. Bb5+ Kd1 (forced) 10. Ne5, etc.  It's probably best for black to not recapture on d5 and allow the c6-pawn to fall as well, so he can at least develop the b1 knight, but this makes it hard for the other knight to hang on to e4.