Are "Brilliant moves" in computer analysis just any decent sacrifice now?

Sort:
Avatar of Optimissed
ItsTwoDuece wrote:

The most simple way to understand how the computer determines brilliancies is as a move which is the best by a large margin and which offers your opponent material in some way. There's more to it I believe, but that's practically it. With that in mind they aren't too rare for tactically minded players willing to sacrifice- usually I'm more level headed when attacking, but I I had one game with 4 (over the board, I was Black here):

I'm sure many other players here have games with multiple as well, it just depends on how you approach attacking.


That's about right. A weaker player may be more likely to get it than a strong one. And I think I noticed a slight tendency for people to get more brilliant moves if they'd already made a bad mistake in a game. I think it's compensation for all the descriptions of moves as blunders and mistakes, so they wanted to bring in great moves and brilliant moves to sort of make people feel better.

Avatar of crimson_chessplayer

I think that a brilliant move is rather really hard and not expected but good move. Sometimes it can just be a simply good move.

 

 

Avatar of ItsTwoDuece
Optimissed wrote:

I think it's compensation for all the descriptions of moves as blunders and mistakes, so they wanted to bring in great moves and brilliant moves to sort of make people feel better.

In my understanding it has less to do with feelings and more that the computer factors in a prior material deficit to it's weight in the moves, especially considering the impact offering material seems to play. I didn't write the code though so I could be entirely wrong here.

Avatar of Sjakie_Trekhakie

i finally got one after a lot of games, was pretty proud of it then read about everyone saying it is not correct and all lol

the game: https://www.chess.com/live/game/67514463867

Avatar of ZZXatu

i played TEN brilliant moves before

Avatar of Andrew67275
ZZXatu wrote:

i played TEN brilliant moves before

bruh I played 124 brilliants

 

Avatar of The_Entirety_Of_Ireland

My main question has been the same for a while; what is the average rating for first brilliant moves?

Avatar of Advanced_player1
GMatchen wrote:

It gave me a "!!" for a simple move. Perhaps b/c most people would just try and check with the Q? And this was a Daily Chess game!

 

 

 

 

you threaten mate

Avatar of Dhanitha10
GMatchen wrote:

It gave me a "!!" for a simple move. Perhaps b/c most people would just try and check with the Q? And this was a Daily Chess game!

dxc4 closes the get-away square(d3) for the wk and creates a checkmate threat on f2 square, but not the engine says that dxc4 is the best move instead Brilliant!!

white to move, wnh3  defending f2, and if we plays cxb3 capturing the wn
they plays wbg5(trapping the bq).

also after playing wbg5, Stockfish laughed at me and played bqxg4. After I play fxg4 he skewerd me with wbxg4+ and took the queen.

 

 

Avatar of Advanced_player1
Dhanitha10 wrote:
GMatchen wrote:

It gave me a "!!" for a simple move. Perhaps b/c most people would just try and check with the Q? And this was a Daily Chess game!

 

dxc4 closes the get-away square(d3) for the and creates a checkmate threat on f2 square, but not the engine says that dxc4 is the best move instead Brilliant!!

white to move, h3  defending f2, and if we plays cxb3 capturing the
they plays g5(trapping the ).

also after playing g5, Stockfish laughed at me and played xg4. After I play fxg4 he skewerd me with xg4+ and took the queen.

 

 

hey, why isn't it brilliant?

Avatar of Anirudh_sai

👀👀👀👀👀

Avatar of RockItRoll643
i think the brilliant move is a 5% chance of getting it maybe?
Avatar of NexusOptimum
I got one on my first game on this account.
Avatar of VishuVenkatesh

I got 11 brilliant moves in rapid and 2 brilliant moves in blitts 11+2=13 brilliant moves!!!!!!!!!!!!

Avatar of exceptionalfork

I've recently seen a spike in the amount of brilliant moves I've done, so I now have a good bit. I think brilliant moves have gotten easier to obtain, which is what I've noticed some other people saying too.

But yes, they were very hard to get in 2020, when this forum was written.

Avatar of KieferSmith

I've played one brilliant move. It was in a game against a bot. The idea was to sacrifice my queen for a bishop. Because that bishop was defending a pawn on the other side of the board, I could take that pawn with my rook, and one move later win the game.

Avatar of MarioParty4

I've only gotten one, and it was a checkmate against someone else after they made a serious blunder.

Avatar of rfc_adam

I got a brilliant move for this, does anyone agree with that?

Avatar of CallenChess

I’ve got lots of Brilliant moves!

Avatar of flyon20
@rfcadam no