...no comments yet? bump!
Nice game at home!
Here are some comments, I did not spend that much time analyzing, so there are probably mistakes in my analysis:
I did not like 6.cxd4, that move is fine in the Italian Game, with your bishop on c4, but not here. I would have played 6.e5, and it could go something like 6...Ne4 7.cxd4 Bb4 8.Nbd2 with a slight edge for white.
I am not sure why you say you win a pawn after your 9th move. You are actually getting back the pawn you gave away, and after the dust settles, you are in a position with even material, an isolated pawn and with 2 knights against 2 bishops. You have no advantage in development, which is what I assumed you wanted to get by giving away the e4 pawn. So I would have to say that after move 10 black has a clear advantage.
It would have been better to play 44.Rh7+ followed by Ra7 (rooks belong behind pawns). After 46...Ra5 you are lost.
wish i couldve done computer analysis but this game was at home..maybe we could he we repeated it on chess.com =D
me vs my brother!!!