the IMPOSSIBLE position

Sort:
Avatar of jupjup12345

What position is well,"impossible" that you can think of?

That is SO impossible...

Avatar of Casual_Joe

Not impossible -- it happened to me once.  I offered a draw and he accepted.

Avatar of Kreattor

Laughing

Avatar of walkerruns2

must have been a garbage draw

Avatar of C-nack

Avatar of Irontiger

I stole someone's idea from another post, but...

Avatar of Scottrf
Avatar of LoekBergman

Avatar of LoekBergman

Avatar of C-nack
LoekBergman wrote:
 

whats wrong with that.

Avatar of Scottrf

Black can't move into check.

Or the other one, knights and bishops are in the wrong place.

Avatar of C-nack
Scottrf wrote:

Black can't move into check.

Or the other one, knights and bishops are in the wrong place.

lol didn't see this knight/bishop swap

Avatar of LoekBergman

In the first diagram should white have had a promotion of a bishop to have two bishops on the same color. But white has still eight pawns and in no way can that promoted bishop return behind its pawns.

In the second diagram scottrf is looking it from a black point of view having a good reason why the position is impossible. However, I thought about the situation of undiscovered checks in which two pieces can give check simultaneously. That is not possible if the two pieces are equal to oneanother and completely impossible if the two pieces are two pawns.

Avatar of LoekBergman

Ha, you were faster!

Avatar of jupjup12345

Good for black.

Avatar of ndrw

Avatar of Scottrf

Knights can't lose a tempo.

Avatar of LoekBergman

Avatar of jupjup12345
Casual_Joe wrote:

Not impossible -- it happened to me once.  I offered a draw and he accepted.

seriosly peoples who has that many queens? 

Avatar of JMB2010
jupjup12345 wrote:
Casual_Joe wrote:

Not impossible -- it happened to me once.  I offered a draw and he accepted.

seriosly peoples who has that many queens? 

No-he's right. It's a known theoretical position since the times of Philidor. It has been played by all of the world champions, with mixed success. Most common move is Qexh5, but some prefer to go with Qgxa4.  Personally I prefer the second option.