Why 3. Qd7??

Sort:
Avatar of mynameismund

I found this move has been played twice by really strong players, Why not take the queen?

https://www.365chess.com/opening.php?m=7&n=104800&ms=e4.c5.Nf3.d6.Bb5.Qd7

 

Avatar of Pawnlings

I assume you mean the opening explorer? That was not played seriously by strong players

Avatar of ArtNJ

 365chess is great, BUT any big free database is going to contain errors.  And this is an error.  No one above beginner strength would play this. 

Avatar of ipcress12

Agree with ArtNJ. It's got to be bad data entry. 

I assume Van Wely and Gelfland actually played 3...Bd7.

Avatar of chesster3145

There are multiple examples in databases of people playing 6. Re1 b5 7. b3!? in the Closed Ruy Lopez.

Avatar of penandpaper0089

Not even Magnus would play this. happy.png

Avatar of pawnintheirgame29

QD7!! Exchanges the horrible queen for a magnificent white squared bishop.tongue.png. I agree with the people that said that this is an error.

Avatar of STEVESMITHFAN49

What!!!!! Qd7 is the best!tongue.png

 

Avatar of Onepiecemania
[COMMENT DELETED]
Avatar of varelse1

I have always played 3...Qd7 here.

What do you guys play?

Avatar of a5page
Bd7 for goodness sake What is wrong with people, you will lose your queen. Is anyone here good at chess?
Avatar of Pawnlings
banana-head wrote:
Bd7 for goodness sake What is wrong with people, you will lose your queen. Is anyone here good at chess?

There's this thing called sarcasm. It's tough to explain. Sometimes people say contradictory things to what is clearly true to everyone else because the absurdity of their claim makes others laugh a bit. 

Avatar of eric0022

3...Qd7 stops the check AND attacks the bishop, so it's a dual-duty move. The bishop sees the big queen bully, screams and runs back to f1 in fear.

 

@banana-head

 

Perhaps the player holding the Black pieces wants to hone his/her playing skills by playing a handicap game. You can generally view it as a blunder in ordinary chess scenarios, but there may be other reasons in favour of doing so. For example, in my local chess club against fellow players. sometimes I do random sacrifices to give my opponents a fighting spirit in the demolition of my game, whilst I manage the position as hard as I can being material down.

Avatar of a5page
PactOfCards wrote:
Bd7 for goodness sake What is wrong with people, you will lose your queen. Is anyone here good at chess?

I still don’t get it ..?

Avatar of blueemu

I checked two of the (complete) games, and it does NOT seem to be a bad data entry. A couple of 2600 players really did play Qd7.

But both were Blitz games.

Avatar of a5page
PactOfCards wrote:
PactOfCards wrote:
Bd7 for goodness sake What is wrong with people, you will lose your queen. Is anyone here good at chess?

I still don’t get it ..?

Yeah but 2600s are meant to be good at chess, i seriously dont understand

Avatar of eric0022
PactOfCards wrote:
PactOfCards wrote:
PactOfCards wrote:
Bd7 for goodness sake What is wrong with people, you will lose your queen. Is anyone here good at chess?

I still don’t get it ..?

Yeah but 2600s are meant to be good at chess, i seriously dont understand

It is quite likely that the player holding the 2600 rating was actually blitzing out the move or had made a premove (and it was too late to reverse the move).

Avatar of VictoryW10
Avatar of magipi
eric0022 wrote:
PactOfCards wrote:
PactOfCards wrote:
PactOfCards wrote:
Bd7 for goodness sake What is wrong with people, you will lose your queen. Is anyone here good at chess?

I still don’t get it ..?

Yeah but 2600s are meant to be good at chess, i seriously dont understand

It is quite likely that the player holding the 2600 rating was actually blitzing out the move or had made a premove (and it was too late to reverse the move).

It's impossible, even in bullet.

The only reasonable explanation is a database error, as it was pointed out 5 years ago.

Avatar of Optimissed
mynameismund wrote:

I found this move has been played twice by really strong players, Why not take the queen?

https://www.365chess.com/opening.php?m=7&n=104800&ms=e4.c5.Nf3.d6.Bb5.Qd7

Not possible to play that.