How important is "My System"?

Sort:
torrubirubi

After working  with some chapter I began to change  positively  my concepts on the importance of passed pawns, outposts and rooks on open lines and 7th  rank. If the book is good enough  for uncountable  strong players, IMs, GMs  and super  GMs, it is good enough for me 😎

kindaspongey

"... Just because a book contains lots of information that you don’t know, it doesn’t necessarily mean that it will be extremely helpful in making you better at this point in your chess development. ..." - Dan Heisman (2001)
https://web.archive.org/web/20140626180930/http://www.chesscafe.com/text/heisman06.pdf
A My System sample can be seen at:
https://www.qualitychess.co.uk/ebooks/MySystem-excerpt.pdf

pureredwhiteblu

Has anyone seen this video series?
Killegar Chess Presents: "My System" by Aron Nimzowitsch

Pikelemi
tazus wrote:

By the way, how does one get to NM? 

By not reading "My System"

Andnar
Pikelemi wrote:
tazus wrote:

By the way, how does one get to NM? 

By not reading "My System"

Very astute

LogoCzar

i think

' .

'my system'

is a worthwhile read

putshort
The way it’s written makes him sound as crazy as Koch.
Clockwork_Nemesis
Fast forward 5 years, was it read and was it worth it?
medelpad
Idk haven’t read it, however a FM told me he didn’t like it cuz it was very dogmatic
Uhohspaghettio1
medelpad wrote:
Idk haven’t read it, however a FM told me he didn’t like it cuz it was very dogmatic

I don't like it either, I don't like Nimzowitsch's writing style or his similaes to real life, he's also kind of passive aggressive. I still can't figure out what point he tries to make about what he calls "hanging pawns" or how it's meant to be useful.

I think Tarrasch's The Game of Chess is the best book for learning the main principles. Honestly I think the whole "hypermodern revolution led by Nimzowitsch" was just a bunch of nonsense. Sure controlling the centre from afar turned out to be better than had been thought, that's not really a revolution, plenty of things turn out different to original theory.

For what it's worth Nimzowitsch came from a wealthy Jewish family, which I found out many years after forming my opinion and it might answer a few questions.

putshort
Reported!