Is 1.e4 for heros and 1.d4 for cowards? elaborate.

Sort:
Scottrf

By one game, hardly a big enough sample.

gundamv

Bobby Fischer, Vishy Anand, and Magnus Carlsen prefer 1e4.

Kasparov and Aronian prefer 1d4.

Looks like both are fine.

Sunofthemorninglight

i'm 3/3 with 1.Nh3

Scottrf
Sunofthemorninglight wrote:

i'm 3/3 with 1.Nh3

You outranked ChristopherSaindon a bit...

Sunofthemorninglight

it's only in the testing phase, but my last win with it was sweet!

Scottrf

I think I heard about it, 1. Nh3 1-0.

Sunofthemorninglight

beat that Chuck Norris!

PUNTHAMURRA

I recently made the switch to d4 after 6-7 yrs of e4 play and I must say as devoted I was to the e4 cause openings such as sicilian and ruy lopez are hard to crack but I find now that I'm winning a lot more with white when I play d4.

Sunofthemorninglight

you're just a bad advertisement for 1.e4, admit it!

AndyClifton
TetsuoShima wrote:
Fischer wasnt nuts. He became world champion and is probably the most famous chessplayer ever....

How can you call such a successful person nuts???

lol

AndyClifton
paulgottlieb wrote:

The first move doesn't determine the chracter of the game: the Berlin Defense to the Ruy leads to a complex, slow maneuvering game after 1.e4. The Botvinnik variation of the Semi-Slav leads to mind-blowing tactics after 1.d4

I agree.  It's like that whole egregious "open/semi-open/closed" games business. (eek!)

GreedyPawnGrabber

e4 is for silly Joe. 1. g3 ! is for fighters that will ultimately become heros

royalbishop

6 pages and still going strong.

pinggo

Kramnik has proved Fischer wrong..Kramnik hypothesis 1.e4 1/2-1/2

gaereagdag

Hey! Then what's 1.Nf3 for? Chess refuseniks? Laughing

And let's not even mention the 1.b3 people. Their brains must be screwy.

PIRATCH
pingo420 wrote:

Kramnik has proved Fischer wrong..Kramnik hypothesis 1.e4 1/2-1/2

Really? Fischer only said: "1 e4 best by test!"

This does not mean White must win beginning with 1 e4. For Fischer it was his best choice! He proved it. (Tal should have played only 1 e4 because his results with 1 e4 were clearly better than any other move he played instead! - A GM - unfortunately I forgot who - once wrote: "Tal should have played only 1 e4 - here he was World Champion. On other openings Tal was 'only' a very strong GM!") Cool

T. V. Petrosian and Kramnik had/have a different chess style. So what was fine for Fischer (and Kasparov - althoug he first played 1 d4) doesn't need to be 'best' for them.

royalbishop

This a site for basically full of e4 players so not going to get much conversation from many d4 players here. Easy win.

royalbishop

5 Best e4 Openings?

PIRATCH

What you can say: Every chess player has to prepare (or cover in his repertoire) 1 e4 and 1 d4 (as well as 1 c4) - either with White or with Black! Cool

Aletool

Is only a matter of taste