today's puzzle

Sort:
timrhayes
I am thinking that today's puzzle is incorrect. Black's move after white's supposedly correct move is sub optimal and causes him to lose the game. White smooth, my move, seems somewhat arbitrary. I don't understand the logicbehind what is considered the ideal move for white.
Martin_Stahl

The puzzles should have the same first move, regardless of black's reply. Most of the time, the puzzle is showing a thematic idea and that is why a given defense is played. Even with best play, the first move should provide some advantage over other potential first moves.