who has deeper chess understanding

Sort:
Avatar of superking500

carlsen or aronian

Avatar of toiyabe

Carlsen.  Duh?

Avatar of Cravingollie

Carlsen

Avatar of superking500

you guys think carlsen has more chess understanding then aronian?

Avatar of AndyClifton

Yeah.  Who has deeper chess understanding than us?

Avatar of PatzerLars

I understand how the pieces move. Is that good ?

Avatar of SeigneurMontjoie

How could we possibly judge? None of us is strong enough to know how deep their understanding goes.

Avatar of superking500

bu,mp

Avatar of AndyClifton

A 2-hour bump?  No come on, that's gotta be an infraction...

Avatar of superking500
AndyClifton wrote:

A 2-hour bump?  No come on, that's gotta be an infraction...

cause you didnt answer it

 

if aronian played magnus style he could be just as strong as him

Avatar of sapientdust

I think Aronian's understanding is about 9.81 (+/- 5), and Carlsen's is about 10.05 (+/- 5), so Carlsen's is a tiny bit deeper.

Avatar of macer75
superking500 wrote:
AndyClifton wrote:

A 2-hour bump?  No come on, that's gotta be an infraction...

cause you didnt answer it

 

if aronian played magnus style he could be just as strong as him

That's just your opinion. IMO right now Magnus>Kramnik>Vishy>Aronian, but of course that's just my opinion, which is just as valid (or invalid) as yours.

Avatar of superking500
macer75 wrote:
superking500 wrote:
AndyClifton wrote:

A 2-hour bump?  No come on, that's gotta be an infraction...

cause you didnt answer it

 

if aronian played magnus style he could be just as strong as him

That's just your opinion. IMO right now Magnus>Kramnik>Vishy>Aronian, but of course that's just my opinion, which is just as valid (or invalid) as yours.

is it cause magnus is stronger then everyone else, or is it his style... he plays it safe, and plays good moves...... what if aronian, kramnik, etc. adapted his style, they would just be as good as magnus, am i right?

Avatar of kco

I'll say Kasparov.

Avatar of macer75
superking500 wrote:
macer75 wrote:
superking500 wrote:
AndyClifton wrote:

A 2-hour bump?  No come on, that's gotta be an infraction...

cause you didnt answer it

 

if aronian played magnus style he could be just as strong as him

That's just your opinion. IMO right now Magnus>Kramnik>Vishy>Aronian, but of course that's just my opinion, which is just as valid (or invalid) as yours.

is it cause magnus is stronger then everyone else, or is it his style... he plays it safe, and plays good moves...... what if aronian, kramnik, etc. adapted his style, they would just be as good as magnus, am i right?

Ok... so Magnus is strong because he plays good moves? That makes sense. The rest of that you probably want to explain in greater detail.

Avatar of AndyClifton
superking500 wrote:
what if aronian, kramnik, etc. adapted his style, they would just be as good as magnus, am i right?

You mean the Really Really Strong Style? lol

Avatar of AndyClifton
kco wrote:

I'll say Kasparov.

Yeah, but you also want to eliminate world leaders!

Avatar of superking500
AndyClifton wrote:
superking500 wrote:
what if aronian, kramnik, etc. adapted his style, they would just be as good as magnus, am i right?

You mean the Really Really Strong Style? lol

yes for example aronian tends to play complex middle games....which is why he loses more then magnus....what if he played like magnus's style...he would be just as good as him

 

magnus tends to play more simple posistions

Avatar of kco
AndyClifton wrote:
kco wrote:

I'll say Kasparov.

Yeah, but you also want to eliminate world leaders!

Firstly he got to be elected then we eliminate him !

Avatar of waffllemaster
superking500 wrote:
AndyClifton wrote:
superking500 wrote:
what if aronian, kramnik, etc. adapted his style, they would just be as good as magnus, am i right?

You mean the Really Really Strong Style? lol

yes for example aronian tends to play complex middle games....which is why he loses more then magnus....what if he played like magnus's style...he would be just as good as him

 

magnus tends to play more simple posistions

When Magnus plays a simple position what kind of position is his opponent playing?