Why Didn't Bobby Fischer Defend HIs World Title?

Sort:
Avatar of onthehouse

Bobby Fischer believed he could name the rules for defending his title and assumed those rules would be acknowledged and accepted. As reigning champion and number one in the world he assumed it was his privilege to have his requests met. When he found out otherwise, out of principle to his own idea of what was right, he refused to play the match. He felt entitled and would not compromise or accept any other outcome than what he expected and imposed. It was either his way or NO way. Period.

There wasn't fear of losing as a motivation for not playing. That idea is absurd and ridiculous. And even though he loved the big paycheck, the prize money was not enough to induce him to go against his own principle.

Avatar of onthehouse
Estragon wrote:
onthehouse wrote:

Bobby Fischer believed he could name the rules for defending his title and assumed those rules would be acknowledged and accepted. As reigning champion and number one in the world he assumed it was his privilege to have his requests met. When he found out otherwise, out of principle to his own idea of what was right, he refused to play the match. He felt entitled and would not compromise or accept any other outcome than what he expected and imposed. It was either his way or NO way. Period.

There wasn't fear of losing as a motivation for not playing. That idea is absurd and ridiculous. And even though he loved the big paycheck, the prize money was not enough to induce him to go against his own principle.

So why did he never contest another tournament?  Or even suggest that he was available to do so? 

What "principle" could possibly mean he should never play again in competition?

Good questions.

Bobby seems to have become somewhat disillusioned with the structure of chess competitions, and he began searching for something more meaningful than a board game. He became more involved in some type of a religious cult. His life sort of took a "left turn" and he drifted away from chess.

Avatar of CalamityChristie
Fear_ItseIf wrote:

fischer being scared of somebody is a stupid assumption.
Look at it this way, fischer was self obsessed with the hugest ego in the world. he said he could beat god with the white pieces, and its my feeling he fully believed he could.

The guy was insane, it wasnt out of fear. I think the insanity got the better of him and he couldnt deal with other people/tournaments anymore.

the first sentence was good, but the rest was a wimp-out!

fischer just didn't have enough fear to keep his big trap door shut.

(yes! that was a joke, i think i may have to explain that in advance)

Avatar of fabelhaft

"Bobby seems to have become somewhat disillusioned with the structure of chess competitions"

Fischer had always been rather critical, but the complaints, results of them and his actions could be contradictory. He played two Candidates tournaments, and then demanded that this should be changed to Candidates matches. When the system immediately was changed according to his wishes he boycotted the next cycle and withdrew from the one after that.

Fischer complained about short draws and because of this FIDE introduced a rule against draws before move 30 in the Olympiad 1962. Fischer took shorter draws in the event, declaring that he didn't have to follow the rules. Before his title match he complained about the Champion having draw odds, but as soon he had won the title he demanded that the challenger should have to win with a margin of two wins to get the title.

Avatar of sirrichardburton

It really doesn't matter why he didn't defend the title, the bottom line is that he refused to defend his title. It seems like in his own mind as long as he didn't lose the title over the chess board he was still the World Champion.Not playing is the only 100% way of making sure you won't lose.The fact that Kasparov defended his title so many time and Fischer not even once puts Kasporov at the top of great chess world champions, and Fischer at the bottom of the list. I don't know who would had won between Fischer and Karpov but i think it would had been an interesting and great match. The fact that it never took place is completely Fischer's fault.

Avatar of PLAVIN81

I was known that he was mentaly ill

Avatar of fabelhaft

Actually, he did defend the title in 1992 according to himself.

Avatar of CalamityChristie

guy had a sense of humour, though not to everyone's taste, i thought it was a blast!

Avatar of netzach

If his health had kept up expect he would have liked to invite Kramnik to Iceland to challenge him for the title ? :-)

Avatar of bigpoison
cabadenwurt wrote:

Johnmusacha: I can assure you that I did not make that rumour up. Mind you I do not know your age but I will admit that it is a older rumour. As far as the KGB was concerned those were not fun people, numerous books have been written about the Spy War part of the Cold War. As for the leadership of the USSR goes I guess the Cuban Missle Crisis shows best that they were prepared to push things quite far.

AndyClifton: " HORSE-POOP ", put that in your Pipe and smoke it  lol. 

Next you'll be saying you think the dh is good for baseball.Tongue Out

It was, in fact, the U.S. that pushed that whole Cuban missile crisis thing too far.  Remember who blinked?  It sure as hell wasn't that nut from Massachusetts.

Avatar of Cokelover

Avatar of Cokelover

1st

Avatar of CalamityChristie

should've posted it in Battlechess format

Avatar of cabadenwurt

Bigpoison: Re the Cuban thing I noticed that Khrushchev barely even mentioned it in his Memoirs ( something to hide perhaps Nikita ? ).

Yes I do have a thread on the go here about the DH in Baseball, a terrific idea that,  lol. Wink 

Avatar of Yereslov

Karpov would have crushed Fischer if he had the chance.

Avatar of Yereslov
Cokelover wrote:
 

That's an awful puzzle.

2. Qc6#.

Avatar of AndyClifton
bigpoison wrote:
It was, in fact, the U.S. that pushed that whole Cuban missile crisis thing too far.  Remember who blinked?  It sure as hell wasn't that nut from Massachusetts.

And all because of that goofy thing in Turkey.

Avatar of azziralc

1.Qc6# is more better.

Avatar of CalamityChristie
Yereslov wrote:

Karpov would have crushed Fischer if he had the chance.

that would have required fischer to give him that chance (unlikely on at least 2 counts)

Avatar of CalamityChristie
Yereslov wrote:
Cokelover wrote:
 

That's an awful puzzle.

2. Qc6#.

it was a joke, not a puzzle, see these things need to be explained!