Why everyone says that chess come from India !?

Sort:
schrodingerforluv

It's because Indiana Jones discovered the pieces buried under some rocks.

Turns out he wasnt an Indian, but you know, a mistake anyone could make i guess :(

WSama
[COMMENT DELETED]
president_max
iluvzmetuna wrote:

It's because Indiana Jones discovered the pieces buried under some rocks.

Turns out he wasnt an Indian, but you know, a mistake anyone could make i guess :(

But the actor who played him, Hari Sampath, definitely was Indian.

fewlio

Maybe chess came from Uranus?

universityofpawns

What do toilet paper and the Star ship Enterprise have in common? Answer they both circle the planet Uranus looking for Klingons.

navalsaini

A brief history of chess. The first mention of chess is found in an ancient Indian text dating back to 5 century AD. It was subsequently developed in Persia and Europe over next few centuries. 

 

https://medium.com/halfchess/a-brief-history-of-chess-e5ceeffdf99e

ESP-918

Yeah only from 5th century AD and what about before? Exactly! It could be from Russia or America or China or ... or exactly no one knows so just because in the 5th century AD it has something to do with India it does not mean it came from India or originated there

navalsaini

Yes quite possible.

ESP-918

Theirs no facts that chess came from India or was originated there, so in that case I say it came from Russia and not India. Why not? I'm just guessing the exact same way you do as its impossible to track it's origins

ESP-918

So on a very serious note, I hate when people give disinformation , especially when asked do you know where chess come from? Oh sure it's India

That's what ennoys me disinformation.

If you ask me the same question, where chess come from? I will answer you , that no one knows. Clear , truthful answer. And earliest country that played chess or changed the rules or whatever, was India, but that's another story.

Alreadygivenup

Mr.Hypothesis...I wonder where you come to exist from!

SquareBlitz
http://en.chessbase.com/post/hindi-and-the-origins-of-chess
This article says that it originated from India. From my understanding you're saying that "probably" or "most likely" does not mean it originated from India for sure. That's the case for history in general. Historians trace the earliest predecessors of the game and assume it from there. So what's bothering me is that you can say that you don't know for sure where anything originated from. Such as noodles, it's traced back to being consumed in China, but you don't know right? Even though it's traced back to China it could be anywhere in the world right? So it doesn't make sense to call it a Chinese dish? What I'm saying is that India is where historians have traced the origins of chess to, if you don't want to believe that then let people believe what they want. There are still people who believe that the earth is flat today, but I'm not going to argue with them or let it bother me lol.

tl;dr: article says that history of chess can be traced back to India. If you don't believe it just because you can't "know for sure" (just like everything in this world) then don't hate other people for their beliefs.
GuessWhoIAm

@ESP-918 -- Where do you come from?

ESP-918

SquareBlitz :

They call it a Chinese dish not because the noodles came from China, it's because of other things

SquareBlitz
Yes but what do you have to say about the article? Why do they call it a Chinese dish? Where other sources say they are possibly from the Middle East and other Asian countries. How can you say it's just a Chinese dish???
ESP-918

Simply because we live in a big lie surrounding us and to avoid people asking to many questions and going all crazy , demanding the answers and creating a K.o. So government created a big fat lie to everyone and say staff that will calm us down, that way it will be easier to control the crowd.

I won't be surprised if we know exact origins of chess, noodles and even our evolution, but we don't know this information, Why it's hidden from us it's a great question that I can't answer.

ESP-918

Unfortunately we just are pawns and our galaxy is a chess board. Go figure. ..

Alreadygivenup

I guess we are all troll baited and the perennial agrument continues blah blah blaa!

Alreadygivenup

Does'nt work man...needs to be hypnotised and history imprinted into his subconsious mind.

Y_U_TAKE_USERNAME
I guess you're an atheist then @ESP-918