when you "smart guys" start talking in all that "mathematical jargon" I typically let you guys go at it for however long it takes in that "boxing ring" -- I have told Elroch numerous times I could never speak in "that language" --- I prefer Elvish
Yes, you are like someone who doesn't know the rules of chess pontificating about the game at odds with all existing knowledge.

Heisenberg and Godel did good work as to discussing the unknowable.
Including with proof.
Good thing they didn't go by Wittgenstein and his 'if we do not know of it we should not speak of it'.
Heisenberg and his good work regarding randomness.
One of the results:
The world now has medical MRI machines.
Although - not enough of them yet.