Hi all,
I was playing at an OTB tournament recently and between rounds was reviewing some listed FIDE and USCF rules. I noticed something that surprised me - it stated not only FIDE but USCF requires players to make their move first, and to only make the scoresheet notation afterward - although there was a note that tournament directors can choose not to enforce this for their tournament.
I have been attempting to review this online here: https://new.uschess.org/sites/default/files/media/documents/us-chess-rule-book-online-only-edition-chapters-1-2-9-10-11-2024.pdfThis seems to be a little confusingly written because first it has section 15A Manner of Keeping Score: "The player must first make the move, and then record it on the scoresheet."
However two paragraphs later under another section labeled 15A Variation One (Paper Scoresheets) I see "The player using a paper scoresheet may first make the move, and then write it on the scoresheet, or vice versa. "
Between the two there is also this tip for tournament directors:"TD TIP: While the rule’s wording indicates making the move first and keeping the scoresheet (paper or electronic) visible at all times, it brings US Chess in alignment with FIDE procedures and soothes many of the fears surrounding electronic scoresheets—see Rule 43— it is a huge change for many players. TDs are advised to first (and possibly second and third) issue warnings to players that do not comply with this revised rule before enforcing any time penalties (1C2a. prescribes adding two minutes to the opponent’s unused time).
Not trying to waste folks' time getting lost in the weeds on this, but I was very surprised as I remember time and again when I was younger, the very common advice to scholastic players was always to write down their move first, look again, and only after double-checking to move the piece. Personally I've always been too impulsive for this (haha) but I am wondering if this is now bad advice and entirely against the rules, or at least contrary to the direction USCF is headed. I don't want to be forced to drink hemlock just because I tell a few young players to write down their moves before making them!
Just curious for thoughts and whether anyone has ever actually seen a player receive a warning or a penalty for this.
----------
As an aside since they're referenced in the quote, one of my opponents was using a little handheld electronic scoresheet in the tournament and I was surprised this is still allowed in 2024, given where we are at with cheating scandals and chess. (Not to imply anything regarding that particular opponent who seemed a fine model of good sportsmanship)