1.e4 Openings HURT/HEAL Game

Caro-Kann 25

Italian 30

Pirc 15

Scotch 15 (-5)

Sicilian 45

Spanish 25

The Caro-kann is easily among the best answers to 1. e4, objectively speaking.

Caro-Kann 25

Italian 30

Pirc 10 (-5)

Scotch 15

Sicilian 45

Spanish 25

Caro-Kann 25

Italian 30

Pirc 5 (-5)

Scotch 15

Sicilian 45

Spanish 25

Caro-Kann 25

Italian 30

Pirc 0 (-5)

Scotch 15

Sicilian 45

Spanish 25

Pirc is eliminated

Caro-Kann 30 (+5)

Italian 30

Scotch 15

Sicilian 45

Spanish 25

Caro-Kann 30

Italian 30

Scotch 10 (-5)

Sicilian 45

Spanish 25

Caro-Kann 30

Italian 30

Scotch 5 (-5)

Sicilian 45

Spanish 25

Caro-Kann 30

Italian 30

Scotch 0 (-5) ELIMINATED

Sicilian 45

Spanish 25

Caro-Kann 30

Italian 25 (-5) 

Sicilian 45

Spanish 25

Caro-Kann 30

Italian 30 (+5)

Sicilian 45

Spanish 25

Caro-Kann 30

Italian 35 (+5)

Sicilian 45

Spanish 25

Caro-Kann 30

Italian 35

Sicilian 50 (+5)

Spanish 25

Caro-Kann 30

Italian 35

Sicilian 45 (-5)

Spanish 25

Caro-Kann 30

Italian 35

Sicilian 50 (+5)

Spanish 25

Caro-Kann 30

Italian 35

Sicilian 45 (-5)

Spanish 25

Caro-Kann 30

Italian 35

Sicilian 50 (+5)

Spanish 25

Wow this got intense

Caro-Kann 30

Italian 35

Sicilian 50

Spanish 30 (+5)

I really like all four of the openings left, so hurting any of them is tough, but I guess my least favorite of the four is the Caro-kann by a small margin.

Caro-Kann 25 (-5)

Italian 35

Sicilian 50

Spanish 30