Flchessplayer, I'm sure you are too thick to evaluate a game properly.
This game was played with 55 mins handicap on me, due to late arrival at the playing hall. The piece sac was an OTB inspiration to end the theoretical discussion (Atalik is very good at that), and isn't bad. Suat has analysed the game on Chessbase Magazine, where he suggests 16...Nxe3 as a better move, but white still winning after 17.Bxe3 ed4 18.Ra5!! Qd7 19.Ne5 etc.
But unfortunately chess is a difficult game. The GM missed in his analyses (me too OTB, of course) the quiet move 18...Qf6! whan after 19.Bg5 Qg6 20.Bxd8 Be6 21.Qc2 Rfxd8 Black has some advantage.
White can keep some advantage only by means of the scary 18.Bxd4 Re8+ 19.Kd1!, which according to the engines is better for white, but the game is a total mess. The position resembles a Colle, although it's clearly more conservative.
The continuation in the game (the Nf2 piece sac) is worse, but instead of the dubious 22...Qd5? (I had just four minutes at that point) and the gross blunder next move, Black is equal after 22...Qb5 or even 22...Qxb1+.
I don't want to distract you any more than that from your Deep Colle analyses. Have a good day.
Yup. You have to be quite a Master ... to play like that.
Are you secretly The_Gavinator or something?