French vs Caro-Kann at the top level?

Sort:
BlunderMaster-123

People said Caro-Kann is the "better French" due to the "French bishop" stuff. But why is French Defense played more than Caro-Kann at Super GM level?

french

For one thing, the French Defense gives White less options.

In the Caro, White's serious options are the Fantasy, Exchange, Panov, Advance, and Classical. In each of those variations, Black doesn't have too many different ways to play (Bf5 or c5 in advance, Nd7 or Bf5 in Classical).

But in the French, White only has 3 options: Classical, Advance, and Tarrasch. There's plenty of choice for Black after each. For instance, after the Classical is chosen by White, Black can play the Rubenstein, the Winawer, or Nf6. And all of those variations, especially the Winawer, has innumerable sidelines, all sound, Black can hide in. As a relatively strong French player, I know of at least 8 different ways Black can play the mainline Winawer.

So, Black gets much more choice in the French.

Also it's a better opening. wink

Ethan_Brollier
BlunderMaster-123 wrote:

People said Caro-Kann is the "better French" due to the "French bishop" stuff. But why is French Defense played more than Caro-Kann at Super GM level?

You answered your own question.

People say Caro-Kann is a better French. 
Super GMs play the French more than the Caro-Kann.

It’s quite simple really, people have absolutely no clue what they’re talking about.

daragonk3

:river :river :river :river :river

ThrillerFan
1e4_0-1 wrote:

For one thing, the French Defense gives White less options.

In the Caro, White's serious options are the Fantasy, Exchange, Panov, Advance, and Classical. In each of those variations, Black doesn't have too many different ways to play (Bf5 or c5 in advance, Nd7 or Bf5 in Classical).

But in the French, White only has 3 options: Classical, Advance, and Tarrasch. There's plenty of choice for Black after each. For instance, after the Classical is chosen by White, Black can play the Rubenstein, the Winawer, or Nf6. And all of those variations, especially the Winawer, has innumerable sidelines, all sound, Black can hide in. As a relatively strong French player, I know of at least 8 different ways Black can play the mainline Winawer.

So, Black gets much more choice in the French.

Also it's a better opening.

Not sure at what point he considers it a "Main Line Winawer" - 4.e5? 7.Qg4? Etc.

But, this should give you an Idea of the number of lines in the winawer alone:

Anti-Winawer: 4.a3, 4.Bd2, 4.Bd3, 4.Qg4, 4.Nge2, 4.exd5, 4.Qd3

Black's 4th move options: 4...c5, 4...Ne7, 4...b6 (4...Ne7 can transpose to the main line after 5.a3 Bxc3+ 6.bxc3 c5, but 6...b6 also possible)

White's 5th move: 5.a3 (main), 5.Bd2, 5.Qg4

Black's 5th: 5...Bxc3+ (main), 5...Ba5

6.bxc3

Black's lines after 1.e4 e6 2.d4 d5 3.Nc3 Bb4 4.e5 c5 5.a3 Bxc3+ 6.bxc3 (in ascending order of importance):

A) 6...b6

B) 6...Qc7 7.Qg4 f5

C) 6...Qa5 7.Bd2 Qa4

D) 6...Ne7 and now

D1) 7.Nf3

D2) 7.a4

D3) 7.h4

D4) 7.Qg4 and now

D4a) 7...Nf5

D4b) 7...O-O

D4c) 7...Kf8

D4d) 7...Qc7 or 7...cxd4

And within those last 3 are NUMEROUS subvariations.