Komodo 9.3 vs Stockfish 7

Sort:
Avatar of Mandy711

Will you post the games won by Komodo? I like to compare their choice of openings.

Avatar of pfren
Mandy711 wrote:

Will you post the games won by Komodo? I like to compare their choice of openings.

Engines do not choose openings, sir. Letting them playing the opening moves would be a disaster.

Whatever choice is due to the openings book they are using.

Avatar of pfren

Yes, it's true that the standard practice in engine vs engine matches is both of them using the same openings book.

Avatar of Adam-Herwis

Sit tight TheSonOfSorrow82 , I started the 40-40 50 game tourney.....

Avatar of Adam-Herwis

It might take days to complete the 40/40 tournament. If you guys request another time control, you are welcome. I don't want this forum to have offensive comments or anger caused by my engine matches. I also don't want to be biased. So be happy @TheSonOfSorrow82 

Avatar of Mandy711

@OP I suggest for your next engine match, a handicap match. Stockfish or Komodo vs Fritz, Junior or Hiarcs. 5 min vs 40 min. I dont have a PC so cant do it myself 😊

Avatar of RookSacrifice_OLD
pfren wrote:
Mandy711 wrote:

Will you post the games won by Komodo? I like to compare their choice of openings.

Engines do not choose openings, sir. Letting them playing the opening moves would be a disaster.

Whatever choice is due to the openings book they are using.

What would be the disaster? Letting then choose opening moves seems more fair to me.

Avatar of Adam-Herwis

When engines choose chess openings, they lead to premature developement of the queen or moves that can be parried easily, here is an example (Engine is Houdini 4 Pro x64) :

Avatar of Adam-Herwis
Avatar of Adam-Herwis

The results of the 40min+40sec tournament is here: 

Komodo won 5 games as white only (again only white): 

 

Avatar of Adam-Herwis
Avatar of Adam-Herwis
Avatar of Adam-Herwis
Avatar of Adam-Herwis
Avatar of Adam-Herwis

While Stockfish 7 won 4 games:

 
Avatar of Adam-Herwis
Avatar of Adam-Herwis
Avatar of Adam-Herwis
Avatar of Adam-Herwis
Avatar of Adam-Herwis

The Results: 

Komodo:   25.5

Stockfish: 24.5

The Ultimate conclusion: 

Komodo is officially stronger than stockfish in slow time controls due to its superior performance as white. However, Stockfish plays way better at faster time controls; the results of the 10 sec 50 game tournament is here (pasted from before): 

Stockfish 7:    30.5

Komodo 9.3:  19.5

Stockfish scored 22% higher than Komodo in this 10 sec tournament.

Stockfish also plays better than Komodo with black in slower time controls. If Komodo 9.3 were to go against stockfish as black only stockfish would probably be the winner.