Ponziani Opening

I have a game where my opponent played Nxf2 and got a lost position but on 7.Qd5 he played 7...Qe7! and there I am convinced White can get no more than a small edge and this may be a fine way for Black to play. He blundered several times afterwards though.

Fabiano Caruana is, of course, a very strong player. If he is in some trouble after his 6th move as Black and is in very deep trouble soon after his 6th move [as Black] it is a good indication that the Ponziani can be played at very high levels.
And for any player rated 2300 or less--it can be a very good opening [if he learns some of the theory].

The current World Champion once played the Ponziani [and won of course]
For 99% of the players--why play the Ruy Lopez which requires ten times as much learning of opening theory as to learn the Ponziani?
If Caruana cannot defend against the Ponziani--your likely opponents may also have a hard time defending against the Ponziani!?

Here is a vote chess game ended a few months back. Easy to find the best moves in vote chess when you have 3 days for one move plus a whole team working together...
The Chess Mine was White...
Opening Ponziani Frasier Variation [this is the most complicated of all
Ponziani variations...]
Here is a vote chess game ended a few months back. Easy to find the best moves in vote chess when you have 3 days for one move plus a whole team working together...
The Chess Mine was White...
Opening Ponziani Frasier Variation [this is the most complicated of all
Ponziani variations...]
Impossible to play like that OTB! Nevertheless a gem!

Well, it helped that I was well versed on that opening variation. \
But you are correct, it is much easier to come up with a master piece in vote chess than it is over-the-board...

Fascinating game, with a knockout blow (and imminent resignation) in less than 35 moves. Black apparently made a number of technical errors, but they were so subtle the vote chess people (apparently) couldn't find them.
Great Game, PONZ. Now if only those boneheads in the "Chess is a Draw with Best Play" thread would sit up and listen to you. Hope Springs Eternal.

Here is a vote chess game ended a few months back. Easy to find the best moves in vote chess when you have 3 days for one move plus a whole team working together...
The Chess Mine was White...
Opening Ponziani Frasier Variation [this is the most complicated of all
Ponziani variations...]
Beautiful one. I think that line is too risky to play otb, but fine in mail chess.

What if, after 1.e4 e5 2.Nf3 Nc6 3.c3 Nf6 4.d4 Nxe4 5.d5 Bc5 6.dxc6 Bxf2+ 7.Ke2, black plays bxc6 instead of Bb6? What is white best continuation?

What if, after 1.e4 e5 2.Nf3 Nc6 3.c3 Nf6 4.d4 Nxe4 5.d5 Bc5 6.dxc6 Bxf2+ 7.Ke2, black plays bxc6 instead of Bb6? What is white best continuation?
White has a piece for three pawns. If White can get his pieces out, he will have an edge in the opening. So, 7...bc6 8.Qa4 followed by Nbd2 should give white an edge. The computer now suggests that 12...e4! as played in Anderskewitz-Ghosh (2016) would have retained approximate equality for Black.