Rank Every Defense Against 1. E4 From Favorite To Least Favorite (In Your Opinion)

Sort:
Avatar of ChessIsFun314159

These are my rankings:

  1. c6 Caro-Kann
  2. e6 French Defense
  3. Nc6 Nimzowitch Defense
  4. g6 Modern Defense
  5. d6 Pirc Defense
  6. b6 Owen's Defense
  7. e5
  8. d5 Scandinavian
  9. c5 Sicilian
  10. Nf6 Alekhine's Defense
  11. Na6
  12. Nh6
  13. a6
  14. h6
  15. h5
  16. a5
  17. g5
  18. f6
  19. f5
  20. b5

As you can see, I like to play really solid openings.

Avatar of pleewo

I’ll give you top 10

1. C5 Sicilian

2. C6 Caro Kann

3. E5 Open Game

4. E6 French

5. D6 Pirc

6. G6 Modern

7. Nf6 Alekhine

8. D5 Scandinavian

9. B6 Owens Defense

10. Nc6 Nimzowitsch

Avatar of Ethan_Brollier
ChessIsFun314159 wrote:

These are my rankings:

  1. c6 Caro-Kann
  2. e6 French Defense
  3. Nc6 Nimzowitch Defense
  4. g6 Modern Defense
  5. d6 Pirc Defense
  6. b6 Owen's Defense
  7. e5
  8. d5 Scandinavian
  9. c5 Sicilian
  10. Nf6 Alekhine's Defense
  11. Na6
  12. Nh6
  13. a6
  14. h6
  15. h5
  16. a5
  17. g5
  18. f6
  19. f5
  20. b5

As you can see, I like to play really solid openings.

*INHALES DEEPLY* 

Caro #1? Owen’s above Open Game and Sicilian? Sicilian NINTH!?

”As you can see, I like to play really solid openings.” Like the Nimzowitsch, which you ranked THIRD???

Ahhh, never mind, you’re a new 1200 with a trollface pfp.

Avatar of ChessIsFun314159
Ethan_Brollier wrote:
ChessIsFun314159 wrote:

These are my rankings:

  1. c6 Caro-Kann
  2. e6 French Defense
  3. Nc6 Nimzowitch Defense
  4. g6 Modern Defense
  5. d6 Pirc Defense
  6. b6 Owen's Defense
  7. e5
  8. d5 Scandinavian
  9. c5 Sicilian
  10. Nf6 Alekhine's Defense
  11. Na6
  12. Nh6
  13. a6
  14. h6
  15. h5
  16. a5
  17. g5
  18. f6
  19. f5
  20. b5

As you can see, I like to play really solid openings.

*INHALES DEEPLY* 

Caro #1? Owen’s above Open Game and Sicilian? Sicilian NINTH!?

”As you can see, I like to play really solid openings.” Like the Nimzowitsch, which you ranked THIRD???

Ahhh, never mind, you’re a new 1200 with a trollface pfp.

Okay, so the reason that I put Sicilian ninth and stuff like that is because I really hate open games because I'm not good at starting an attack and am bad at defending.

Also, the Nimzowitch is a playable opening, and so is the Caro-Kann

Yes, I am 1200, but at the time of writing, I have been gradually improving and am currently at my peak.

And I do have a trollface profile picture. Do you like it?

Avatar of Ethan_Brollier
ChessIsFun314159 wrote:
Ethan_Brollier wrote:
ChessIsFun314159 wrote:

These are my rankings:

  1. c6 Caro-Kann
  2. e6 French Defense
  3. Nc6 Nimzowitch Defense
  4. g6 Modern Defense
  5. d6 Pirc Defense
  6. b6 Owen's Defense
  7. e5
  8. d5 Scandinavian
  9. c5 Sicilian
  10. Nf6 Alekhine's Defense
  11. Na6
  12. Nh6
  13. a6
  14. h6
  15. h5
  16. a5
  17. g5
  18. f6
  19. f5
  20. b5

As you can see, I like to play really solid openings.

*INHALES DEEPLY* 

Caro #1? Owen’s above Open Game and Sicilian? Sicilian NINTH!?

”As you can see, I like to play really solid openings.” Like the Nimzowitsch, which you ranked THIRD???

Ahhh, never mind, you’re a new 1200 with a trollface pfp.

Okay, so the reason that I put Sicilian ninth and stuff like that is because I really hate open games because I'm not good at starting an attack and am bad at defending.

Also, the Nimzowitch is a playable opening, and so is the Caro-Kann

Yes, I am 1200, but at the time of writing, I have been gradually improving and am currently at my peak.

And I do have a trollface profile picture. Do you like it?

Sure, but ninth is… somewhat unreasonable.

With the Nimzowitsch, ranking it third is interesting as after 2. Nf3 it transposes directly to the Open Game which you ranked seventh. Sure, the Caro is playable but it CERTAINLY isn’t the best. It doesn’t deserve the number one spot, and as much as I hate to say it as a French player, I don’t think the French deserves number two.

I’m glad to hear that! I hope you stick with it and keep improving long into the future.

Yeah, I do like it. Trollface will always be just a little funny no matter how dumb the meme is.

Avatar of ChessIsFun314159
Ethan_Brollier wrote:
ChessIsFun314159 wrote:
Ethan_Brollier wrote:
ChessIsFun314159 wrote:

These are my rankings:

  1. c6 Caro-Kann
  2. e6 French Defense
  3. Nc6 Nimzowitch Defense
  4. g6 Modern Defense
  5. d6 Pirc Defense
  6. b6 Owen's Defense
  7. e5
  8. d5 Scandinavian
  9. c5 Sicilian
  10. Nf6 Alekhine's Defense
  11. Na6
  12. Nh6
  13. a6
  14. h6
  15. h5
  16. a5
  17. g5
  18. f6
  19. f5
  20. b5

As you can see, I like to play really solid openings.

*INHALES DEEPLY* 

Caro #1? Owen’s above Open Game and Sicilian? Sicilian NINTH!?

”As you can see, I like to play really solid openings.” Like the Nimzowitsch, which you ranked THIRD???

Ahhh, never mind, you’re a new 1200 with a trollface pfp.

Okay, so the reason that I put Sicilian ninth and stuff like that is because I really hate open games because I'm not good at starting an attack and am bad at defending.

Also, the Nimzowitch is a playable opening, and so is the Caro-Kann

Yes, I am 1200, but at the time of writing, I have been gradually improving and am currently at my peak.

And I do have a trollface profile picture. Do you like it?

Sure, but ninth is… somewhat unreasonable.

With the Nimzowitsch, ranking it third is interesting as after 2. Nf3 it transposes directly to the Open Game which you ranked seventh. Sure, the Caro is playable but it CERTAINLY isn’t the best. It doesn’t deserve the number one spot, and as much as I hate to say it as a French player, I don’t think the French deserves number two.

I’m glad to hear that! I hope you stick with it and keep improving long into the future.

Yeah, I do like it. Trollface will always be just a little funny no matter how dumb the meme is.

In the Nimzowitch, after 2. Nf3 you can play other things like 2... d5. But I guess that transposes to the Scandinavian. You're right about that.

Avatar of pleewo

I mean, as long as number 1 is one of e5, c5, e6 or c6, I’d consider it a W. An even bigger W if the top 2 include two of those. And a massive W if the top 4 were those 4.

Avatar of sidespaghetti
I want to know how the St. George Defense is placed below both Na6 and Nh6
Avatar of Refrigerator321
ChessIsFun314159 wrote:

These are my rankings:

  1. c6 Caro-Kann
  2. e6 French Defense
  3. Nc6 Nimzowitch Defense
  4. g6 Modern Defense
  5. d6 Pirc Defense
  6. b6 Owen's Defense
  7. e5
  8. d5 Scandinavian
  9. c5 Sicilian
  10. Nf6 Alekhine's Defense
  11. Na6
  12. Nh6
  13. a6
  14. h6
  15. h5
  16. a5
  17. g5
  18. f6
  19. f5
  20. b5

As you can see, I like to play really solid openings.

Can I borrow your weed because it must be some good stuff after hearing that take

Avatar of UserDavidK

I know this kid irl he is very crazy. Also why is e5 7th when Owen's is 6th?? I think the Caro is good for beginners though. Put Sicilian higher, Owen's lower, Nimzowitch lower, and this might be a little ignorant of how good it can be, but Pirc lower.

Avatar of Refrigerator321
d4iscrazy wrote:
 

AlphaZero defense

Avatar of ChessIsFun314159
UserDavidK wrote:

I know this kid irl he is very crazy. Also why is e5 7th when Owen's is 6th?? I think the Caro is good for beginners though. Put Sicilian higher, Owen's lower, Nimzowitch lower, and this might be a little ignorant of how good it can be, but Pirc lower.

Thank you David for calling me crazy. Also, to clarify, I meant for you guys to rank it from best to worst IN YOUR OPINION, or your favorite to least favorite. But it might have been a wording problem on my part though.

Avatar of ChessIsFun314159

I changed the title sorry guys

Avatar of ChessIsFun314159
PotatoesAndChess wrote:

Sicilian NINTH?! Caro FIRST?! Nimzowitch THIRD?!

the OWENS DEFENSE over THE OPEN, SICILIAN, AND THE SCANDINAVIAN??!!

you're crazy

Let me sincerely thank you for calling me crazy. It's not like I don't read my own forum.

Avatar of AngryPuffer

people enjoy the caro? whats so fun about it?

Avatar of ChessIsFun314159
AngryPuffer wrote:

people enjoy the caro? whats so fun about it?

It’s just a solid opening that some people like because of that

Avatar of Hydrahta

S. Sicilian and Scandinavian
A. E5, Nimzowitsch, and Caro-kann
F. Anything Else

Avatar of Hydrahta

i do not enjoy the caro. it blocks ur own knight and me no likey

Avatar of Hydrahta

I wouldnt want to castle kingside anymore, and i also just gave up the center

Avatar of Hydrahta
d4iscrazy wrote:
Hydrahta wrote:

I wouldnt want to castle kingside anymore, and i also just gave up the center

it's called a joke.

like what ur mom made

sorry i had to