@Ronald: I'm pretty sure I contributed to some of those accidents the past two nights... of course, so did the next bar they went to after mine...
But getting back to your main point, and probably the main point of this thread. One thing I wouldn't be for is separating paying and non-paying members, as well as playing and non-playing members, as far as who would get the "privilege" to post in the forums. I actually think the members themselves already do a lot of the monitoring of the forums by either ignoring people, or making fun of people who are here soley to annoy, so I don't think I would change much of anything. But that's just my tiny opinion:)
If Macer (and his sockpuppets) disappeared tomorrow he'd be largely forgotten by March.
I don't know about that? I've heard about the Cheater_1 person for years. Kco would probably lament the total disappearance of this Musascha person. I'm sure Macer would be a part of more people's memory than we can possibly imagine if he were to leave. Chess.com peeps sometimes actually enjoy having those types of personalities around, I think
That's you. You are a regular poster. Most of the forum users (by quantity, not volume of posts/replies) are occasional/casual and couldn't give a hoot about any of the trolls.