Morphy the Terrible

Sort:
Avatar of Yereslov

Here is a game showcasing how terrible and overrated Moprhy has become:



Avatar of Scottrf

If only you could find those moves without your computer!

Avatar of Yereslov

I have more games Scott. 

Avatar of ivandh

Pretend I photoshopped a chess piece in

Avatar of ivandh
Yereslov wrote:

I have more games Scott. 

Parcheesi? Solitaire?

Avatar of Yereslov
ivandh wrote:
Yereslov wrote:

I have more games Scott. 

Parcheesi? Solitaire?

I meant chess.

Avatar of mrguy888

For a list of people who don't play terrible chess according to Yereslov's standard can be found here.

Avatar of Scottrf

Avatar of Yereslov

If a man is considered the greatest player in history, then his games should reflect that title. Morphy played terrible moves. What's the point of appreciating  a game for its attack on the king, if the attack is just an illusion? All the moves are refuted through analysis. A player of Morphy's calibre has no excuse.

Avatar of ivandh

So you're saying that, because he is such a great player, he is a bad player?

Avatar of Yereslov

How can he be a great player if all his games are based on luck? His attacks have no poison to them. All of his games are easily refuted. You can't say the same for Steinitz or Lasker. Steinitz was far more precise, and his attack are not easy to refute. He saw farther ahead.

Avatar of DrSpudnik

The world's greatest troll has resurfaced for another round of abuse from the fans of chess!

I'll bite: Yereslov, if you could play anything half as crappy as Morphy on a day when he had a migrane or hangover, I'd be impressed. Why don't you publish one of your gems to illuminate just how much better you are than the sucky Paul Morphy!

Avatar of mrguy888
Yereslov wrote:

How can he be a great player if all his games are based on luck? His attacks have no poison to them. All of his games are easily refuted. You can't say the same for Steinitz or Lasker. Steinitz was far more precise, and his attack are not easy to refute. He saw farther ahead.

Yeah he was consistanly lightyears ahead of all of his competition because he was lucky.

By the way I am the world champion of coin flipping and when I roll dice they always land on 6 unless I don't want them to. I also win the lottery every week. It is all skill.

Avatar of ivandh
Yereslov wrote:

How can he be a great player if all his games are based on luck?

Are you talking about parcheesi again?

Avatar of mrguy888
DrSpudnik wrote:

The world's greatest troll has resurfaced for another round of abuse from the fans of chess!

I'll bite: Yereslov, if you could play anything half as crappy as Morphy on a day when he had a migrane or hangover, I'd be impressed. Why don't you publish one of your gems to illuminate just how much better you are than the sucky Paul Morphy!

http://www.chess.com/forum/view/general/yereslovs-immortal

Avatar of Doggy_Style

Do you know the exact circumstances of this game?

 

Was it a casual game or a blindfold game or....?

Avatar of Yereslov
mrguy888 wrote:
Yereslov wrote:

How can he be a great player if all his games are based on luck? His attacks have no poison to them. All of his games are easily refuted. You can't say the same for Steinitz or Lasker. Steinitz was far more precise, and his attack are not easy to refute. He saw farther ahead.

Yeah he was consistanly lightyears ahead of all of his competition because he was lucky.

By the way I am the world champion of coin flipping and when I roll dice they always land on 6 unless I don't want them to. I also win the lottery every week. It is all skill.

How is he lightyears ahead when his attacking moves always lead to equality? He lived in an era of terrible players. Had he played Steinitz, he would have had his butt handed to him. 

Avatar of Yereslov

Compare Morhy's games to Steinitz or Lasker's. Far better quality, and far more accurate.

Avatar of Scottrf

But he didn't play Steinitz. And he wasn't playing 2012 Houdini.

It's like saying Bannister was a terrible runner because people have run 3.43 miles now.

Avatar of zborg
Yereslov wrote:

Compare Morhy's games to Steinitz or Lasker's. Far better quality, and far more accurate.

Welcome Back @Yereslov.  Apparently, they let you out on a weekend pass, and the hurricane did the rest.  Smile