Please, don't switch to the English as long as you play like this. You tend to create too many weak squares, and the English is (basically) all about avoiding this.
This being said, you are playing well over your rating, I would say around 1500 or more.
(and post in the 'analysis' forum).
Your comments in "quotation marks"
I usually play this opening as white, or something similar to it when faced with a Sicilian.
I think I'm having second thoughts though, and I'm probably going to start leaning towards the English c4.
Heres a gameplay of me against a higher ranked player, who played the scotch game:
Brought to you from the mind of an 1100 high school student.