Collide,
You may just be becomming a more defensive player. There's nothing wrong with that. Think about Tigran Petrosian.
Also, you dont know if this will be a permanent change. It sounds like you want to play more aggressively so I would guess your style will continue to change over time as you get more comfortable.
I'm rated around 1800 USCF and after a month of OTB tournament after tournament, I recently noticed that I am paranoid about EVERYTHING. What I mean by this is:
1) I overanalyze everything. I calculate variation after variation and don't seem to trust my own judgement. (Needless to say, this causes me to run into time trouble)
2) I overexaggerate the bad parts of my position. For example, if I end up having an isolated pawn, I'll panic and worry about how horrible it is and end up thinking that I have a slightly worse position than my opponent (if everything else is fairly equal or unclear). Another example: I won't go into an unclear variation because although I might have a slight advantage from it, my opponent will also gain something and that makes me reject the variation entirely (even if my advantage from the variation is better than my opponent's).
What is there to do? Seek therapy?
Thanks.