W

Sort:
Avatar of ilikecapablanca

There is a reality beyond language; language was created by us.

Anyway, it's 1:40 AM here, so I'll make a disappearance. Good night!

Avatar of fischerman_bob

Einstein showed that time is the 4th dimension.

Avatar of Trash_Aesthetic

not our imaginations but the content of our imaginations (that never make it to "(un)reality"

Avatar of Trash_Aesthetic

4d world contains 3d world yes but their spaces are differencet

Avatar of Trash_Aesthetic

yes 4d world has no "space" just time which contains the space

Avatar of Trash_Aesthetic

therefore chess as an idea in time exists, but once we act on it it ceases to exist and the existence becomes but a trace, a flame, a spark, a shadow

Avatar of Trash_Aesthetic

therefore "chess" as it is today emphatically does NOT exist

Avatar of Trash_Aesthetic

Good night!

Avatar of Chewie1200

Language, thought, it all comes down to our perception of reality in the end doesn't it?  

But it's inherent, I believe, for us to think that there is a concrete, physical reality and only one, with the possibilities of its future being endless.

Avatar of halfgreek1963

Didn't DesCarte say I think therefore, I fart?

Avatar of SarahLikesChess
Does the wall behind u exist?if u cant say for certain its there without turning round then it doesnt.existence is all chemical.
Avatar of Chewie1200
Fiveofswords wrote:
Trash_Aesthetic wrote:

fiveofswords its clear objects dont exist, we agree. a "line" is an idea (a "4d" thing) not a reality (we call things lines but...

the fact that a line is an idea is irrelevant to the fact that a line can be finite while being composed of an infinite number of points or indeed an infinite number of finite distances (so long as their length converges towards zero). Therefore since your argument is not true in general, it therefore is not true in the specific category of empirical objects.

while you said points in your original post on the subject you do have a point with an infinite number of finite distances.

Chess exists! We'll leave it at that.

Avatar of Skynet

Chess is a temporary construct of a feeble human intellect trying desperately to justify an existence that is without meaning or purpose.

Avatar of fischerman_bob

Greek philosophy BS? Ummmm it was the foundation of western society. It also redirected us from superstition and towards rational thought. I am a big fan of rational thought. I guess you are not.

Avatar of Catrina-Volokitten
halfgreek1963 wrote:

Didn't DesCarte say I think therefore, I fart?

it was "i stink, therefore i farted maybe".

Avatar of Trash_Aesthetic
GreekTheZorba wrote:
fischerman_bob wrote:

Greek philosophy BS? Ummmm it was the foundation of western society. It also redirected us from superstition and towards rational thought. I am a big fan of rational thought. I guess you are not.

it's irrelavant today. it may have influenced lots of philosophers in history because there was nothing else worth reading. but rational thought really started with renaissance and wasn't exactly matured until descartes. 

Greek philosophy as scientific knowledge was never the point. it is to be wise as socrates said 'i am wiser than others because although they know nothing they think they do whereas i accept that i know nothing.' and plato always ending in aporias, the goal was to 'empty' oneself out. 

Avatar of Trash_Aesthetic

or 'fill' oneself, depending on how you look at it. this seems clear. something exists and something does not . and this is supported by the fact that if something exists, it means it is not the other thing

Avatar of Johnny_Climaxus

These posts are very interesting, thank you!

A couple of things to sum up the discussion -

There are things which exist and which do not exist.

The world itself, as a concept exists, but nothing in the world exists.

Therefore, chess does not exist.

Correct?

Avatar of Johnny_Climaxus

Also see the new forum of what the self that plays chess is

Avatar of KillTheHorsie

... to sum up the discussion???  The discussion, and the thread, exist until the last comment is posted.  And that's not up to any one of us.  even then it will continue to exist in a digital form.

Avatar of Guest4518923294
Please Sign Up to comment.

If you need help, please contact our Help and Support team.