is Gukesh a better player than Magnus Carlson

Sort:
Avatar of pfren

Gukesh got his IM title when he was 12 yo, and he had hardly studied any chess opening. He was playing the same KID-related stuff with both colors, and weird nontheoretical Scandis and Hippos.

But his positional understanding was top notch already.

Avatar of DreamscapeHorizons

Here's Kasparovs opinion on who the best player in the world is.

https://indianexpress.com/article/sports/chess/garry-kasparov-hot-take-gukesh-vs-ding-liren-world-chess-championship-9647724/

Avatar of LieutenantFrankColumbo
Mathnerd2015 wrote:
LieutenantFrankColumbo wrote:

Better? No. Best? Yes. Hes the world champion Someone needs to remind bro how many times Magnus won the World Champion

Magnus Carlsen has won the Classical World Chess Championship five times. He won the title in 2013, 2014, 2016, 2018, and 2021.

That doesnt change the fact that Gukesh is the world champion right now.

Avatar of Salopian57

Gukesh is miles away from Magnus he would get hammered in a long match against Magnus, Kasparov sausage is all when Nagnus decided to not defend his title he had retained 5 times when Kasparov stated a world chess champion has to be the two best players abd since the best player is not competing its a 2nd best championship. Gukesh will struggle to defend his title Whoever he faces I think he will struggle??

Avatar of sawdof

At this point we need a dance off.

https://www.facebook.com/watch/?v=1049861192975414

Avatar of DogMallow

Yeah maybe some day it will change but right now Magnus is clearly better then Gukesh

Avatar of asthik2014
pfren wrote:

He certainly is. That guy Carlson isn't even 2000-rated.

i am not that guy

Avatar of Salopian57

I think world chess as far as the world title is in a sad place, not one world champion since Magnus decided to walk away as demonstrated worthiness, this is not anyone's fault but as Kasparov as stated and i agree, stating: You cannot have a world chess champion crowned with distinction if the best chess player in the world is not competing.

And the last world championship between Gukesh and Ding was not very exciting afair filled with bad error's on both sides so to end on a blunder was very apt, Kasparov when asked about the championship his response was... one word SAD?

Avatar of gamerretic928
pfren wrote:

He certainly is. That guy Carlson isn't even 2000-rating

Avatar of gamerretic928

Magnus Carlson is the best player gukesh is also really good but Magnus is way better

Avatar of pfren
gamerretic928 wrote:

Magnus Carlson is the best player gukesh is also really good but Magnus is way better

Dunno any player with the name "Magnus Carlson". Do you?

Avatar of EvilEmpyre
prolly not
Avatar of Salopian57

Everyone knows even Gukesh himself that Magnus is still the best player, Gukesh would have lost his world championship if he had been playing how he did against Ding, fact is Gukesh made a lot of poor choices during some key middle game positions and Ding never took advantage Gukesh will have to play a lot better when he faces either of the top 3 favourites in Caruana ,Hikaru or Giri and Gukesh hasn't played very consistent as late that's got to improve by a good 35% to stand any chance?

Avatar of magipi
Salopian57 wrote:

Everyone knows even Gukesh himself that Magnus is still the best player,

Magnus Carlson? Are you sure about that? Absolutely sure?

Carlsen hasn't even retired yet, and people are already forgetting his name. I find this very sad.

Avatar of vavger56

are we dead-ah gng, Magnus is better