I'm not sure about top 10, but my top 5 would be:
1. Kasparov
2. Karpov
3. Anand
4. Fischer
5. Carlsen
edit: I don't know how I can compare these, but somewhere on the list I would like to shove in: Morphy, Alekhine, Rubinstein, Kramnik and Capablanca.
Kasparov 1st 11
Capablanca 2nd 8
Lasker 2nd 8
Fischer 2nd 9
Alekhine 3rd 8
Karpov 3rd 7
Carlsen 3rd 6
Morphy 3rd 5
Botvinnik 4th 4
Anand 4th 3
Steinitz 5th 3
Spassky 5th 3
Topalov 6th 2
Tal 7th 2
Larsen 8th 1
Kramnik 9th 1
Anderccen 10th 1
Chirov 11th 1
Ivanchuck 12th 1
Short 13th 1
Bronstein 14th 1
Korchnoi 15th 1
Rubensein 16th 1
Smyslov 17th 1