Why did a moderator remove 1000 reply thread???

Sort:
Avatar of AndyClifton

On the plus side, we did get to see that kitten pic (rest assured that no cats or other pets were harmed during the posting of these photos).

Avatar of Knightly_News

What may not be obvious is that derailing the thread because some posters took it off topic doesn't do justice that the thread had an on topoc basis and much discussion on topic that was misfiled as off topic. So to do right thing in the spirit of pettiness the mods committed wrongs and abused their authority. To subjectively apply their religion and say they don't respect the concept of psychic masterS and to censor an on topic post for that reason is just religious persecution. The mod was wrong. no way around it

Avatar of AlCzervik

Psychosis is a religion?

Avatar of goldendog
reflectivist wrote:

What may not be obvious is that derailing the thread because some posters took it off topic doesn't do justice that the thread had an on topoc basis and much discussion on topic that was misfiled as off topic. So to do right thing in the spirit of pettiness the mods committed wrongs and abused their authority. To subjectively apply their religion and say they don't respect the concept of psychic masterS and to censor an on topic post for that reason is just religious persecution. The mod was wrong. no way around it

You were posting about UFOs. You were as off topic as any. Don't blame some posters.

So now the move to off topic was motivated by religious bias?

Ridiculous much?

Avatar of TheGrobe
reflectivist wrote:

What may not be obvious is that derailing the thread because some posters took it off topic doesn't do justice that the thread had an on topoc basis and much discussion on topic that was misfiled as off topic. So to do right thing in the spirit of pettiness the mods committed wrongs and abused their authority. To subjectively apply their religion and say they don't respect the concept of psychic masterS and to censor an on topic post for that reason is just religious persecution. The mod was wrong. no way around it

Chess hadn't been mentioned for hundreds of posts.  On what basis, exactly, did it belong in General Chess Discussion?

Avatar of Conquistador
goldendog wrote:
reflectivist wrote:

What may not be obvious is that derailing the thread because some posters took it off topic doesn't do justice that the thread had an on topoc basis and much discussion on topic that was misfiled as off topic. So to do right thing in the spirit of pettiness the mods committed wrongs and abused their authority. To subjectively apply their religion and say they don't respect the concept of psychic masterS and to censor an on topic post for that reason is just religious persecution. The mod was wrong. no way around it

You were posting about UFOs. You were as off topic as any. Don't blame some posters.

So now the move to off topic was motivated by religious bias?

Ridiculous much?

Well, the mods are the Gods.  Their words are not to be denied and they carry Thor's banhammer to have their words heard.

Avatar of AlCzervik

Not even Spiderman is free from their wrath.

Avatar of netzach

Reflectivist:

hmm.

Only started 3 new topics today that's not good. Better do another.

Okay...

''What if?''

''Chess-player woke up one-morning to discover (chess-pieces) were all made out of cheese!''

''Thoughts/opinions please?''

Yes!!

haha.

That's a good-one. I'll do it...

http://www.chess.com/members/view_content/reflectivist

Avatar of Stevie65

Reflectionist are you trying to appease yourself by suggesting that you had nothing to do with the conduct of your own thread...It was bollux anyway!  Get a grip of your forums man, If you dont control your forums someone else will...most wanted it in off topic anyway...so they can have a laugh!

Avatar of AndyClifton

Chess.com's recently opened religious persecution annex:

Avatar of Knightly_News

AlCzervik wrote:

Psychosis is a religion?

====

Just your opinion. You cannot rule out the possibility of psychic masters except with your own religion. So to ban the topic because of your own religion is religious persecution. You are just another Fascist hiding behind a safe social position

Avatar of goldendog
reflectivist wrote:

AlCzervik wrote:

Psychosis is a religion?

====

Just your opinion. You cannot rule out the possibility of psychic masters except with your own religion. So to ban the topic because of your own religion is religious persecution. You are just another Fascist hiding behind a safe social position

Naw. He's well above average.

Avatar of AndyClifton

Maybe so, but when Al does decide to go a little wild he really floors it!  Here he was all dressed up for last year's Hooker's Ball:

Avatar of netzach

Alien-trained fascists are formidable.

Avatar of Knightly_News
AndyClifton wrote:

Maybe so, but when Al does decide to go a little wild he really floors it!  Here he was all dressed up for last year's Hooker's Ball:

 

Don't try to get laughs dude.  A great wrong has been done here!  We can banter and say it is no big deal in the scheme of things, trivialize it, you can mock me, deride the thread, but what we can't do is say that the moderators really did the right or fair thing, in principle, all things considered.  It was really just a subjective call and an abuse of power.

The thread had a large on-topic component and the fact that it veered was not an excuse to kill the thread.  Lack of activity would have made it die a natural death in its own due time.  There was no clean reasonable fair way to do that thread in. 

And, as you, perhaps better than anyone here knows, I have no sense of humor at all.  Zero.  None. Zilich.  Nada.  Negatory. Finito. So I am incapable of seeing the humor in any of this and have zero objectivity..  Hell to the no!  I understand the strengths and weaknesses of the arguments for and against.  I'm just saying the moderator wronged me and the community because of his religious bias and not out of any accurate sense or application of justice.  

Avatar of corrijean

It really isn't that big a deal to have it moved to off topic. It is still active and anyone who is interested can still follow it. It still shows up in the Hot Topics list.

Religious discussion isn't allowed in the forums, so if that is the basis of your claim you'd better scrap it.

Avatar of AndyClifton

Doggone it, I do believe that recidivist done went and hooked us!...

Avatar of netzach

Blast!

Avatar of AndyClifton

Dang, there went my perfect bottom-of-the-ninth tater. Frown

Avatar of Knightly_News
corrijean wrote:

It really isn't that big a deal to have it moved to off topic. It is still active and anyone who is interested can still follow it. It still shows up in the Hot Topics list.

Religious discussion isn't allowed in the forums, so if that is the basis of your claim you'd better scrap it.

It isn't.  My post was not religious.  It is being persecuted by people with a flawed form of skepticism that turns the skepticism away from objectivity and into a religion of subjectivity and bias in and of itself.  So banning the thread with that skepticism is religious persecution, because it is being persecuted by religion, as religion, when it is not religion, and has a scientifically defensible basis.  Governments and militaries have put a lot of money and research into paranormal phenomena, and there is evidence to support that psychic phenomena and telepathy exist.  It was a perfectly valid topic for the General Chess Discussion forum, as per its charter.  Removing it because it moved at least temporarily to the subject of UFOs and to kill the valid part of the thread because of it, was just bad moderating.