Does True Randomness Actually Exist?

Sort:
noodles2112

If the earth is actually not moving anywhere ........... where is randomness then? 

Elroch

Everywhere.

And all motion is relative. That means it only makes sense to say something is moving w.r.t something else.

Acceleration, however, is absolute.

Thee_Ghostess_Lola

pick a atom out & try2follow it - its kinda fun !...Brownian Motion

...i slowed it down some...here:

...tho now it looks kinda choppy - o well.

noodles2112

looks like heliocentric theory to mewink.png 

czechsalmon
Theoretically no but mentally yes because why would you suddenly think of that or do that or whatever in your head mentally it’s random but mathematically or theoretically no because everything has a meaning and everything has an explanation so no
czechsalmon
Like #7 has a meaning it’s to explain the mental randomness by talking about something completely off topic but it also has a explanation that’s it’s "random" and this forum is asking if it’s real and he think so because it’s "random"
noodles2112

random/happenstance ......what's the difference? 

czechsalmon
#8 it’s not because theoretically you say something what might make sense somewhere in the universe because the universe is infinite what = to infinite patterns making me typing this exact thing and every single think to ever happen to humanity was same "theoretically if the universe is infinite" and so that means also infinite worlds of what you said was true
czechsalmon
But of course we’re not in physics or math class so I’m gonna say it’s true because more people use the "mental randomness" just like me I also use it more so technically yes
czechsalmon
This question is really opinion wise
czechsalmon
Actually if the universe isn’t infinite but it’s infinite old it still counts because that means it’s contained and in billion years it will kinda explode and reform himself all new like if you put an apple there it will be rotten soon but in a billion years it will be nice and red again
noodles2112

finite/infinite ........bedazzling man from birth to death. 

czechsalmon
You talk about infinity so did I do I don’t know if you’re talking "randomness" or I just don’t understand
czechsalmon
My English is not the best sorry..
noodles2112

no apology necessary. 

if something is random, say like the stars, how did they decide the distances? 

factually or theoretically? 

Elroch

It is a philosophical question whether the question of whether the Universe is finite is a scientific question or not!

The reason is that while it is conceivable that it could be experimentally determined that the Universe is finite, it is inconceivable that it could be determined that it is infinite in a finite time. So at any time the most you can know is that the Universe is "bigger than X". Thus as a hypothesis it could never be checked.

However, a counterargument is that there are many scientific hypotheses that are only ever checked in one direction. Eg the hypothesis that the fine structure constant is constant can never be proven. Rather it just gets failed to be disproven. So the hypothesis that the Universe is infinite can have that status - consistent with the evidence and never disproven.

Elroch
noodles2112 wrote:

no apology necessary. 

if something is random, say like the stars, how did they decide the distances? 

factually or theoretically? 

If the arrangement of your living room is random, how can you measure distances?

Your question makes no sense. The distance to relatively near stars is determined by the surveyor's technique of triangulation. And it works well.

czechsalmon
@Elroch what do you think and why you are the creator of this and the last forum so you must know the best from all of us!
czechsalmon
Also I meant that you were the most active in the last on I know uke created also why did he block you?
Elroch
czechsalmon wrote:
Also I meant that you were the most active in the last on I know uke created also why did he block you?

It was a response to me posting the fact that quantum physics disproves determinacy in our Universe. Check the record if you wish. (I was able to edit my last post after being blocked).