Putting a decimal point in front does not alter the result.

Sort:
Avatar of One_Zeroth

9 does not equal 10

99 does not equal 100

999 does not equal 1,000

.999 does not equal 1. A decimal point with 9 billion 9's still has a remainder and it ain't 1!

Get my drift?

Avatar of SriyoTheGreat

what is 1/3

Avatar of One_Zeroth
SriyogeshS wrote:

what is 1/3

10/30

Avatar of SriyoTheGreat

no seriously

Avatar of One_Zeroth

Well 3/9 differs from 3/10

See?

Case Closed!

Avatar of Hawksteinman

1/3 = 0.333...

Avatar of Hawksteinman

1/3 = 0.333..., multiply both sides by 3: 3/3 = 0.999...

Avatar of SriyoTheGreat

so 2/3 = 0.6666666666...

so 3/3 = 0.9999999999...

but at the same time 3/3 = 1

so 1 = 0.99999999999999...

Now tell me where I went wrong zeroth

Avatar of One_Zeroth

I just thought of something, Brilliant!

9/9 does not equal 9/10

9/99 does not equal 99/100

See if you can discern the pattern!

Avatar of shadowhb123
But if 3/3 = 1
And 3/3 also seems to equal 0.999999
Wouldnt the more logical thing be to assume that 0.33333 isnt an exact representation of 1/3 since it infinite for that reason?
Avatar of One_Zeroth
shadowhb123 wrote:
But if 3/3 = 1
And 3/3 also seems to equal 0.999999
Wouldnt the more logical thing be to assume that 0.33333 isnt an exact representation of 1/3 since it infinite for that reason?

It just goes on and on, but it doesn't hit it.

Like a guy who talks too much in a date. Or something that you all represent.

Avatar of SriyoTheGreat
One_Zeroth wrote:
shadowhb123 wrote:
But if 3/3 = 1
And 3/3 also seems to equal 0.999999
Wouldnt the more logical thing be to assume that 0.33333 isnt an exact representation of 1/3 since it infinite for that reason?

It just goes on and on, but it doesn't hit it.

Like a guy who talks too much in a date. Or something that you all represent.

how? I'd like to see you link up some sources.

Avatar of Luna_Lovegood_is_the_best

????? I am so confused 😕 so 1/3 is 0.33333 but 3/3 is 0.99999 but 0.999999 does not equal 1 whereas 3/3 DOES equal one? Does that make sense?

Avatar of SriyoTheGreat
BookwormDS wrote:

????? I am so confused 😕 so 1/3 is 0.33333 but 3/3 is 0.99999 but 0.999999 does not equal 1 whereas 3/3 DOES equal one? Does that make sense?

that is what the whole argument is about

Avatar of One_Zeroth
BookwormDS wrote:

????? I am so confused 😕 so 1/3 is 0.33333 but 3/3 is 0.99999 but 0.999999 does not equal 1 whereas 3/3 DOES equal one? Does that make sense?

Yep. It does DUDE!

Avatar of illegalthingy
Again do you think we are idiots
Avatar of Luna_Lovegood_is_the_best
SriyogeshS wrote:
BookwormDS wrote:

????? I am so confused 😕 so 1/3 is 0.33333 but 3/3 is 0.99999 but 0.999999 does not equal 1 whereas 3/3 DOES equal one? Does that make sense?

that is what the whole argument is about

Yeah, but as always, I'm late to the conversation.

Avatar of One_Zeroth

How come 3 is not a third of 10? And 33 is not a third of 100?

And written as 1 billion 3 is not a third of 10^9. It simply CAN'T transpose or covert.

Avatar of One_Zeroth

Bump

Avatar of One_Zeroth

As Infinitesimals they are just 1/infinity apart, but aren't there. They are never terminating to 1, from 0.999...