A Bust to the Sicilian Defense

Sort:
Tja_05

staples13 wrote:

uri65 wrote:

 

Just look at statistics from master games - it's roughly equal for white and black.

Just look at the statistics from my games. out of 581 games White wins 68 % black wins 26% and there is a draw 6%. That is a score of 71%. No other opening is capable of scoring 71%.

Against what kind of opposition? What strength? What time control? If I played a thousand 1300 to 1500s in regular blitz (Game/5) , I could play the Anderssen or The Vienna or the King's Gambit, and likely score at least 80%!

kindaspongey
SpiderUnicorn (~5 days ago): "ma boy, the title to this pointless forum is already wrong, as you have already mentioned, you have lost 26% of your games with the Alapin, that proves that it is not a refutation to the Sicilian, m'boy"
HolographWars (~5 days ago): "Well, i would play the Alapin any day if it gave me a 74% chance of a win!"
TremaniSunChild (~4 days ago): "U-ummm.... Should I tell him that draws exist a well?"
HolographWars (~1 day ago): "... With a 75% win rate, I’ll play it forever!"
HolographWars wrote (~2 hours ago):

Okay, 74% WIN RATE. Still playin it all day every day.

staples13 (August 27, 2018): "... Just look at the statistics from my games. out of 581 games White wins 68 % black wins 26% and there is a draw 6%. That is a score of 71%. ..."

TremaniSunChild (~1 hour ago): "Against what kind of opposition? What strength? What time control? If I played a thousand 1300 to 1500s in regular blitz (Game/5) , I could play the Anderssen or The Vienna or the King's Gambit, and likely score at least 80%!"

uri65 (August 27, 2018): "I am glad you have your personal success with Alapin but statistics of some 1600 player is meaningless for claims you make in first line of your post #1."

HolographWars

The reason staples13 loses to the Sicilian sometimes is because his opponents are stronger. He can (and I can) wreck opponents of "equal strength".

kindaspongey

uri65 (August 27, 2018): "I am glad [staples13 has] personal success with Alapin but statistics of some 1600 player is meaningless for claims [that staples13 made] in first line of ... post #1."

HolographWars

Rating is just there to correctly group players in tournament s. A 1200 can make a correct statement. Duh.

kindaspongey

You mean staples13 was correct when he wrote that 2.c3 is "the defining move of the Alapin variation"?

staples13
rychessmaster1 wrote:
Wow 1k posts

Yes thank you all for 1000 posts of detailed analysis, debate, and exploration!

kindaspongey
kindaspongey wrote:

"staples13 ... U showed your own analysis, with some nonsense and bad moves from black which don't prove anything. U just proved u lack some objectivity and skill to assess moves/positions." - IM pouncin (September 26, 2018)

https://www.chess.com/forum/view/chess-openings/a-bust-to-the-sicilian-defense?page=12

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

staples13
kindaspongey wrote:
kindaspongey wrote:

"staples13 ... U showed your own analysis, with some nonsense and bad moves from black which don't prove anything. U just proved u lack some objectivity and skill to assess moves/positions." - IM pouncin (September 26, 2018)

https://www.chess.com/forum/view/chess-openings/a-bust-to-the-sicilian-defense?page=12

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

It’s ok I’ve forgiven him for his rude comments. It’s time for you to forgive him too!

Tja_05

*Sigh* This is gonna be a long thread...

Tja_05

....And after I say that, no one posts. OF COURSE

Tja_05

....And after I say that, no one posts. OF COURSE

fried_liver-attack
TremaniSunChild wrote:

....And after I say that, no one posts. OF COURSE

It is a dead thread by now. 

GANHEII
fried_liver-attack escreveu:
TremaniSunChild wrote:

....And after I say that, no one posts. OF COURSE

It is a dead thread by now. 

is it

BeastBoy06

Staples13, the weirdest &$*# in the world

staples13
BeastBoy06 wrote:

Staples13, the weirdest &$*# in the world

I’ve been called worse

Prometheus_Fuschs
staples13 escribió:

Foolish materialistic engine.

Nc3

Oh the irony, I can't just stop laughing.

El_Chapeau12

The Alapin is obviously no bust to the sicilian defence. In the worst case scenario, black transposes to a good french.

 

fried_liver-attack
Tal125555 wrote:

The Alapin is obviously no bust to the sicilian defence. In the worst case scenario, black transposes to a good french.

 

says the French guy

Prometheus_Fuschs

I have noticed a contradiction in the OP, if the Sicilian is indeed losing by force, then it's not an opinion that the Sicilian is a bad opening, however, the OP claims both! CONTRADICTION I CALL!