anything wrong with this opening

Sort:
chesschamp1020

is there anything wrong with this opening? plz everybody answer  would love insight thanks

Beelzebub666

It's a solid opening for white, the scotch game.  Black doing NxN leaves the main line and is a poor move for black since it gives white a big lead in development.

 Better options for black there are nf6 or bc5


redhotman

I start most games like this

Im glad you started this becuase i sometimes get scared i am doing something wrong 

 


chesschamp1020
your welcome red I'm also about to start a Sicilian discussion please join
TonightOnly
werewolf wrote: Beelzebub666 wrote:

It's a solid opening for white, the scotch game.  Black doing NxN leaves the main line and is a poor move for black since it gives white a big lead in development.

 Better options for black there are nf6 or bc5


 The main line is :

4...Nf6  5.Nc3 Bb4  6.Nxc6  Bxc6  7.Bd3 d5!  8.exd5 cxd5  9.0-0 0-0  10.Bg5 Be6  11.Qf3 Be7  12.Rae1 Rb8  13.Nd1 c5

and black is OK...


 I think Beelz hit it on the head. The Scotch is a perfectly good opening, used occasionally by Kasparov. 4...Nxd4 is a terrible move, ceding any control of the center that black had, and getting rid of all his developed pieces. I checked various databases, and 4...Nxd4 was easily the worst scoring fourth move for black. chessgames.com

 

4...Nf6 was the old main line, but 4...Bc5 has become more popular.  4...Qh4 is also played, where chances are about the same, but draws are much less common.

 

TO 


BigHogDogg

Black should not play Nxd4, as QxN afterwards is a slight development lead by white since his queen is developed.  Unlike openings like the scandinavian, there are no moves which develop and threaten at the same time for black.