The Best Player Who Never Became WC?

Sort:
batgirl

Tschigorin and Blackburne both had potential.

RoaringPawn

I think the pics chosen show pretty much the true character of contestants.

One exception though.

The Terrible, that fork aside, is unnaturally peaceful looking😆, don’t ya think?

RoaringPawn
batgirl wrote:

Tschigorin and Blackburne both had potential.

Hey @Batgirl, great you’ve stopped by!

Chigorin is already there, need to find a nice pic/cartoon of Blackburne to add.

Perhaps our friend @simagnfan as a close relative may have one!

So Batgirl, you splitting between the two you mentioned?

RoaringPawn
SynysterGates0101 wrote:

Korchnoi, Bronstein, Keres, Rubinstein...

Only two I’m afraid. So you split between the first two, Victor and Devik?

Thanks!

RoaringPawn
SynysterGates0101 wrote:

Rubinstein, Kortschnoj, then.

Okey-dokey, Akiva and the Terrible then!

Thanks again👍

simaginfan

The earliest picture of Blackburne.

RoaringPawn
SynysterGates0101 wrote:

Chucky is Ivanchuk?

Yes, correct; Chucky, the UA genius!

RoaringPawn
simaginfan wrote:

The earliest picture of Blackburne.

Yo mate. Thanks really. Would people recognize him in his tender years though as I haven’t named the players?

No cartoon, perhaps?

simaginfan
RoaringPawn wrote:
simaginfan wrote:

The earliest picture of Blackburne.

Yo mate. Thanks really. Would people recognize him in his tender years though as I haven’t named the players?

No cartoon, perhaps?

Yep, there is a well known one in one of my posts - from Westminster papers. Will dig it out

simaginfan

introuble2

I don't know who would be the best but I think he should be on the list too

RoaringPawn
simaginfan wrote:

Wow, this is soo coooll!

Thanks mate. Zdravo bio i veseo!

RoaringPawn
simaginfan wrote:

Being not quite clear how to make use of it on the cell, will do it asa I get home after work. Thanks again, mate, awesome stuff👍👍

simaginfan
RoaringPawn wrote:
simaginfan wrote:

Being not quite clear how to make use of it on the cell, will do it asa I get home after work. Thanks again, mate, awesome stuff👍👍

You are welcome! Unusual for me to be sending you pictures - usually the other way round!!!grin.png

simaginfan
introuble2 wrote:

 

I don't know who would be the best but I think he should be on the list too

Good shout!

RoaringPawn
introuble2 wrote:

I don't know who would be the best but I think he should be on the list too

Absolutely, I’m not in any trouble with that — on the contrary! 

Zuckertort, something like Sweet (of sugar) cake must definitely go onto the list!

And think who your pick (or two) may be and let us all know, okay? And thanks👍👍

gingerninja2003
DamonevicSmithlov wrote:

I wonder who the weakest wc is considered, Steinitz maybe?

Hard question, but probably Max Euwe, although Max Euwe was a sensational player nonetheless. Or maybe one of the FIDE WCC like Alexander Khalifman. 

gingerninja2003
SynysterGates0101 wrote:

stupid category. i'd say some of the "FIDE WCHs" are the weakest, but still a stupid category. "weak World Champion"

Topalov was the only one of the FIDE WCCs that was actually good enough to be champion, the rest aren't.

RoaringPawn
DamonevicSmithlov wrote:

I wonder who the weakest wc is considered, Steinitz maybe?

Damon, that was exactly the idea that first sprang to mind this morning before I posted this. If you don’t mind I wouldn’t say weakest, rather one with the least attractive play for some.

Steinitz was a great thinker, that is why I always had high praise of him. Think about it, we had only few real thinkers in the entire history of our game who were able to  explain and put their ideas down. Who came later? Dr Lasker, Nimzo, Reti, who else? Maybe Watson, or Dydyshko in modern times (The Logic of Modern Chess of the latter is totally unknown of in the West).

I highly recommend that you check the blog of my good friend @simaginfan who has recently blogged on Steinitz and his Ideas. Great read!

RoaringPawn
darwinwasright wrote:

there are only 2 people that need be on this list

Keres

Korchnoi

and keres beat korch 4-1-12

Darwin, are these two who have evolved to your two picks for the context? Should I make an update?