you do not need to brag about beating me i thought the witch was the most important piece
There's a rating, so I told matin. There's so many games we sometimes have to tell him.
you do not need to brag about beating me i thought the witch was the most important piece
There's a rating, so I told matin. There's so many games we sometimes have to tell him.
It's worth about 7 pawns.
@evert823 I've been waiting to play a game with those pieces!
Shall I start our thread then? I can moderate the game.
The value of the witch is not just the amount of leapers, but also depends if there is a good outpost for the witch and if the position is opened/closed. Closed = better for the witch.
@Fly-Eagles-Fly's definition is good. I wouldn't really trust any specific value set for it. It really depends on the position how useful it is.
By the way, I have offered to trade my witch against @Junebug444's knight in 2 games (1 ongoing). In neither game has he accepted my trade. I don't think I value the witch nearly as highly as most people here
I actually have wanted to play Clash of Mythic Titans(see starter post) for a long time now.
Yes, I have been thinking about that variant a lot myself. I wonder how it would be... Probably chaotic
Here my last move was Wh6. It's true that I am up a piece, but regardless of that, I would be happy if white traded with Nxh6 ixh6. It would improve my pawn structure. A knight and improved pawn structure sounded more than enough to me, despite the position being quite closed and there being many pieces left, which should benefit the witch.
The value of the witch is not just the amount of leapers, but also depends if there is a good outpost for the witch and if the position is opened/closed. Closed = better for the witch.
@Fly-Eagles-Fly's definition is good. I wouldn't really trust any specific value set for it. It really depends on the position how useful it is.
By the way, I have offered to trade my witch against @Junebug444's knight in 2 games (1 ongoing). In neither game has he accepted my trade. I don't think I value the witch nearly as highly as most people here
Exactly!
How do you value a bishop v. knight? BY THE POSITION.
The value of the witch is not just the amount of leapers, but also depends if there is a good outpost for the witch and if the position is opened/closed. Closed = better for the witch.
@Fly-Eagles-Fly's definition is good. I wouldn't really trust any specific value set for it. It really depends on the position how useful it is.
By the way, I have offered to trade my witch against @Junebug444's knight in 2 games (1 ongoing). In neither game has he accepted my trade. I don't think I value the witch nearly as highly as most people here
I think it’s the opposite. I think people overvalue the witch.
The value of the witch is not just the amount of leapers, but also depends if there is a good outpost for the witch and if the position is opened/closed. Closed = better for the witch.
@Fly-Eagles-Fly's definition is good. I wouldn't really trust any specific value set for it. It really depends on the position how useful it is.
By the way, I have offered to trade my witch against @Junebug444's knight in 2 games (1 ongoing). In neither game has he accepted my trade. I don't think I value the witch nearly as highly as most people here
I think it’s the opposite. I think people overvalue the witch.
false! It saves lives! Once it saved a trapped queen!
And it gets queens too. I lost by the witch to JohnHS!
Yes, of course I believe in my own evaluation, so it is others that overvalue it.
I believe YOU undervalue it!
It's great for attacking, versatile, but I'd say it starts as 5.5 to 6 pawns and deceases in value per sliding piece. With 2 rooks but no bishops or queens, it's about worth a minor piece.
The witch can be quite useful in opposite side castling and the opponent moves a pawn in front of the king
In other news, I just beat @Junebug444 to defend my champion title.
The witch can be quite useful in opposite side castling and the opponent moves a pawn in front of the king
In other news, I just beat @Junebug444 to defend my champion title.
...EXACTLY!!!
The witch can be quite useful in opposite side castling and the opponent moves a pawn in front of the king
In other news, I just beat @Junebug444 to defend my champion title.
...EXACTLY!!!
Wait, can I challenge you?
By the rule of needing a level-two victory, a lot of people can challenge Martin0, I think. That's why the system needs reworked. There's a thread for discussion in the bulldog chess forum.
I have a feeling that no matter how good rating/results I get I will not manage to convince some people what the value of the witch is. I don't think there is much point in me arguing.
The forum regarding the next challenger (which was hoping to be done before this game finished, but apparently was not)
https://www.chess.com/clubs/forum/view/how-is-the-bulldog-world-champion-decided
By the rule of needing a level-two victory, a lot of people can challenge Martin0, I think. That's why the system needs reworked. There's a thread for discussion in the bulldog chess forum.
Yes, the system needs to be reworked and/or upgraded. I'd like to turn this responsibility over to a federation. It might be similar to the International Chess Federation (also known as FIDE, or "Fédération Internationale des Échecs or World Chess Federation").
If anyone would like to be a member of this federation please visit the link above (post by by Martin0).
I actually have wanted to play Clash of Mythic Titans(see starter post) for a long time now.
Our game of Waterloo was pretty interesting, but now you want to play even a bigger game (more pieces and more complex)? That's pretty ambitious.
I was discussing Clash of Mythic Titans with its developer (@BattleChessGN18) and I don't consider the game to be completely finished. He got 99% there, but I think it's currently not playable.
The first task would be to finalize the rules, and present them in a single place where it is easy to understand. Will be fun to see someone try it.
I can moderate this game, but I'll be travelling for about 1 week from about May 10 - May 17. During that time there might be delays (can't logon every day). Time spent waiting for a board update doesn't count as playing time (3-day time control). If you both would like to play please reply here and I'll start a thread.
The way I've read as a way to value the witch is by how much it helps with maneuverability. The more long range pieces (Bishops, Rooks, and Queen) still on the board, the more powerful witch is.
It's a variable:
1+s (slider pieces)