Chess tournaments should have 1) metal detectors, 2) no electronic devices allowed, 3) no cell phone reception, 4) no spectators.
Not bad idea.
What about wooden solitary house deep in the forest, no electricity, only fireplace, mechanical clocks and wax candle's light.
Chess tournaments should have 1) metal detectors, 2) no electronic devices allowed, 3) no cell phone reception, 4) no spectators.
I posted earlier that for the highest level of play, there should be cubicles or booths of some sort, that have amenities for comfort and securities against cheating. I think that if you didn't have to smell your opponents breath or hear him cough or sneeze, that would be great. Lighting and temperature control would be a plus. I am sure many of the past players would have wanted things like this.
If there was no cell phone service available and a camera that is monitored for each player, there is less likelyhood of funny business. If the players are segregated from not only each other, but the audience who is watching on a monitor screen in a waiting area, no one has to be distracted, nor is there a very good possibility of hand signals passed along. If the booths have adjacent restrooms and the players/rooms are checked for electronic devices prior, it would certainly reduce the likelyhood of problems. I realize these things would cost more, but I am certain many players would applaud such efforts. Though, I think some people would be opposed, because it takes away the personal nature of the game. I think many people have always been at odds over that very issue to begin with. It is difficult to argue with fair circumstances that are somewhat customizable for personal preferences. If the players were able to play through an electronic device, such as computers and see each other on a seperate monitor ( this is even possible to make available reciprocally upon request by each party ) and communicate by typing, even having their languages translated. The latter item could be handled by either translators who monitor, or perhaps there is software sophisticated enough to handle the endeavor.
I certainly think the WCC for both men and women should be held under this format and perhaps some of the other major tournaments, such as candidates matches.