Guitar or Piano?

Sort:
Avatar of teri-udon
Loki_god_of_deception wrote:

piano has more emotion

Arguable. Acoustic guitar sounds more intimate & emotional, in my opinion.

Avatar of Loki_god_of_deception

did u read my last comment?

Avatar of teri-udon
Loki_god_of_deception wrote:

u can play 10 notes at once where in guitar u can only play a few at the same time

The 6 to ten difference isn't very large, because it only relates to chords and melodious segments can be done with finger style.

Avatar of KismetPlayzGD

You can staccato on guitar too btw

Avatar of Loki_god_of_deception
KismetPlayzGD wrote:

Change my mind just listened to blues on guitar guitar DESTROYS piano

How far the piano has fell.....on u I hope (jk)

Avatar of teri-udon
Loki_god_of_deception wrote:

(just saying) staccato is smth u can't do in guitar and is very nice.

Slap bass guitar? Palm mute? Inform yourself before making such a claim.

Avatar of KismetPlayzGD
Nate_Pi wrote:
KismetPlayzGD wrote:
Loki_god_of_deception wrote:

there's a reason all the composers chose piano

Cuz the composers your talking about are from 1700-1800 guitar was popular at 1900s

So piano is popular for a longer span of time

''Popular''' doesn't count it's like saying who's better P Diddy or a unknown nice person.

Avatar of Loki_god_of_deception

I counted how many ppl liked piano more, it's 7:3 piano is 7, guitar is 3. guitarists are outnumbered by pianists, just like their keys

Avatar of KismetPlayzGD
Loki_god_of_deception wrote:

I counted how many ppl liked piano more, it's 7:3 piano is 7, guitar is 3. guitarists are outnumbered by pianists, just like their keys

Piano is keyyed and guitar is fretted and stringed and a normal guitar has 24 frets with 6 strings so 6x24 is 144, so it's 144 notes while a piano is only 88

Avatar of KismetPlayzGD

The forum started 7 hours ago let time decide.

Avatar of KismetPlayzGD
idott-box-im-sorry wrote:

I know there’s nothing I can say that could ever make up for what I’ve done, but please, hear me out. I’ve done terrible things, things I can’t take back, and every day, I live with the weight of those choices, haunted by every face, every name. I’m not asking for your forgiveness because I deserve it—I’m asking because I want to change. I want to make something better out of whatever’s left of me. I see now what I couldn’t before; I see the pain I’ve caused, the lives I shattered. And if you can find it in yourselves to let me try again, I swear, from the deepest part of me, that I’ll spend every day trying to make things right. Thank you for giving me even this moment to say what I should’ve said a long time ago.

I’m sorry—I should’ve been clear about this sooner. My family’s been going through a rough time ever since the divorce, and I know that’s no excuse, but it’s weighed on me in ways I didn’t want to admit. Losing that foundation, that sense of stability… it threw me off balance, and I let myself spiral, making one bad choice after another, trying to drown out feelings I didn’t want to face. It’s not fair to blame my actions on something outside myself, but I know now how much that pain clouded my judgment. I see it clearly now—how I hurt others because I couldn’t deal with my own hurt. All I can do is try to rebuild, step by step, and if you’re willing to let me, I want to start making things right.

YOU'RE THE FAMOUS IDIOT BOX!

Avatar of OleWilhelm
GuitarTuna
Avatar of OleWilhelm
Wath is happening with my comment i scripded guitar
Avatar of BlackPlusWhite
I feel like piano is better as a solo instrument
like by itself, no vocals or other instruments
Avatar of teri-udon
I_gray_I wrote:
I feel like piano is better as a solo instrument
like by itself, no vocals or other instruments

Yeah, I agree. However, with a backing track, guitar easily surpasses piano with a backing track. Vocals boost the gap even more.

Avatar of Nylon-Sock-100
I’m now learning to play the jaws harp ! ✌️🤓
Avatar of kittyBOSS56
I think piano is better because you can play a wider range of songs. for example, on piano you can play the Tetris theme and actually make it sound like the Tetris theme. (If you can play the Tetris theme on guitar congratulations you proved me wrong! And please tell me cuz I want to know)
Avatar of KismetPlayzGD
kittyBOSS56 wrote:
I think piano is better because you can play a wider range of songs. for example, on piano you can play the Tetris theme and actually make it sound like the Tetris theme. (If you can play the Tetris theme on guitar congratulations you proved me wrong! And please tell me cuz I want to know)

You can play the tetris theme on guitar!

Avatar of LJGoomba

Both😎

Avatar of kittyBOSS56
#64 no I can’t but I want to know if someone else can